Quantcast
Tor Forge

Science fiction. Fantasy. The universe. And related subjects.
RSS

Latest Posts

› archive

Latest Comments

› show all

Hot Bookmarks


Blog Archive


posted Sunday January 11, 2009 10:54am EST

Gene Wolfe Book Club

John Klima

This time of year, people often think of resolutions—things they want to change from how they did them last year. Never mind that the Gregorian calendar change is completely arbitrary (and not even necessarily the calendar that everyone uses) so you could declare a resolution at any point, at any time.

Regardless, I, too, get caught up in the resolution making. For the past few years (six or seven at least) I’ve resolved to average a book a week over the course of the year. For some this is slow, for others this is fast. For me, it was an aggressive pace, but one I felt I could easily achieve.

Oh how having responsibilities (like full-time work, or a family, or publishing a magazine, or blogging, or...you get the idea) proves you wrong.

If I got to 35 for the year, I was very happy with myself. And considering that median is nine books/year for women and five for men, I was doing pretty good. But it wasn’t the goal I had set out for myself.

This year, I read 53 books. There were some graphic novels, and some standalone novellas, but everything was published as a book so I counted it. I ended up reading three books over my holiday vacation so I could meet the goal. I was very proud in my accomplishment, and to celebrate I gave myself an even tougher goal for this year: read 12 books.

You see, these are no ordinary 12 books; these are the Solar Cycle by Gene Wolfe. The books are The Book of the New Sun [which is comprised of The Shadow of the Torturer, The Claw of the Conciliator, The Sword of the Lictor, and The Citadel of the Autarch], The Urth of the New Sun, The Book of the Long Sun [which is comprised of Nightside the Long Sun, Lake of the Long Sun, Caldé of the Long Sun, and Exodus From the Long Sun], and The Book of the Short Sun [which is comprised of Blue’s Waters, In Green’s Jungles, and Return to the Whorl]. These books are dense and complicated and full of mysteries and things to discover. And at 12 books, that means one a month, which I think is an attainable goal.

I was all set to post my resolution online, when I saw Hugo-nominated author Christopher Rowe make the same resolution. At that point, I had only resolved to “read my Gene Wolfe books” while Christopher made it more formal at one book a month. When I mentioned to him that I was making the same resolution, he strong-armed me into creating an online book club, since I’m a librarian and all that.

To that end, I’ve created—with the help of Mr. Rowe, Mark Teppo, and William Shunn—the Gene Wolfe Book Club. Our reasoning is that while the Solar Cycle books are fun to read on their own, discussing them with other people greatly enhances your reading. We also know that this book club is ambitious, but if we all pull together, I think we can do it. Even if you aren’t able to commit to all 12 books, but want to partake in the discussion, please come over and chat; the more the merrier.

We are looking for people to be moderators. We want to get enough people so that moderating isn’t a burden on any one person.

Open discussion of each book will begin on the 20th of the month in which it’s due. This month we have The Shadow of the Torturer open already in case people want to get started in their discussion. As of January 20, the discussion will begin in earnest. We are working from the current Tor/Orb editions that are in print, though some of us have other editions.

ReddIt Stumble Upon del.icio.us Digg It Send via Mail
BOOKMARK
PRINT

categories: Written Word
tags: gene wolfe, solar cycle, book of the new sun, book of the long sun, book of the short sun

23 comments
Damien G. Walter
1.  Damien G. Walter
Sunday January 11, 2009 11:29am EST
What a coincidence...I just started reading The Book of the New Sun again last night. Its my second attempt. It is as you say John, dense and complicated and full of mysteries and things to discover. So I'm in!
Damien G. Walter
2.  overtheseatoskye
Sunday January 11, 2009 12:39pm EST
Coincidental happenings here too - I just bought the first two volumes yesterday! Better get reading. Thanks for arranging this!
zaphod beetlebrox
3.  platypus rising
VIEW ALL BY · Sunday January 11, 2009 12:40pm EST
This year, I read 53 books.I was very proud in my accomplishment

Just because I'm a very evil man:How to read 462 books in one year

And she's a very insightful and perceptive critic who moves freely from crime to sci-fi to literary,not Harriet Klausner.
Rajan Khanna
4.  rajanyk
VIEW ALL BY · Sunday January 11, 2009 12:45pm EST
I am so totally in. I read the first two a few years back, but I could use the excuse to read them again and plow on to the second set of two.
Damien G. Walter
5.  jere7my
Sunday January 11, 2009 12:45pm EST
Well, heck. I just re-read them last year. I don't think I could justify reading them again. But they're among my favorite books ever, especially Long Sun and Short Sun, so I am a bit jealous. Have a fabulous time!
Jason Ramboz
6.  jramboz
VIEW ALL BY · Sunday January 11, 2009 01:20pm EST
This is fantastic! Gene Wolfe is a fantastic author, but a very difficult one in many ways. I think starting a book club like this can help a lot of people find the enjoyment in his books without some of the frustration that can accompany it. Or at least, you'll know you're not the only one frustrated with it--sometimes it's good to hear someone else say "Yeah, I don't understand it either, but damn is it cool."

I've actually been meaning to read some more Gene Wolfe in the near future, too. I've read all the Solar Cycle (with the exception of Urth of the New Sun which I started but never finished) and the Soldier series, and I'd love to check out his other stuff. Interestingly, I actually started with The Book of the Long Sun, not realizing that it was... well... maybe not a sequel, exactly, but related to something else. Still, I loved it, and went on (through a roundabout process which I won't bore you with here) to read the others.

The thing about Gene Wolfe is that he doesn't create worlds for you. He expects you to join him in creating the world. Instead of filling in all the gaps, he just hints at things and leaves it to your imagination to finish it. That's why, I think, these are the perfect books to discuss in a community. Let's all join Gene in poking at the future together.
John Joseph Adams
7.  johnjosephadams
VIEW ALL BY · Sunday January 11, 2009 01:36pm EST
I wish I had time to participate in this--what a great idea for book club discussion. Books like these that are so complex would be great to read as a group and then discuss afterward. I was completely blown away by The Book of the New Sun when I read it a couple of years ago, but there's no way to appreciate everything it's doing on first read.
gwern branwen
8.  gwern0@gmail.com
VIEW ALL BY · Sunday January 11, 2009 02:02pm EST
Is there any particular reason you guys are starting your own club instead of using an existing forum like the Urth.net mailing list?
Jason Ramboz
9.  jramboz
VIEW ALL BY · Sunday January 11, 2009 02:54pm EST · amended on Sunday January 11, 2009 02:54pm EST
Whoops, accidentally double-posted. Sorry!
Evan Leatherwood
10.  ELeatherwood
VIEW ALL BY · Sunday January 11, 2009 04:49pm EST
Strange. I just bought the first two myself the other day. Guess I will have to join up!
Anthony Ha
11.  AnthonyHa
VIEW ALL BY · Sunday January 11, 2009 05:44pm EST
Wow, I never knew that people called it the "Solar Cycle." I do not approve.
Damien G. Walter
12.  mkb
Sunday January 11, 2009 07:36pm EST
I'm in, as well. I re-read NEW SUN a couple of years back, but hadn't finished the full cycle.

Should be fun to walk through this again, and with others. NEW SUN was not the same book at in my late 40s than it was twenty-five years ago.
John Klima
13.  john_klima
VIEW ALL BY · Monday January 12, 2009 12:25am EST
@8 The reason for creating the book club rather than joining in on the conversation on urth.net was to give some structure to reading all 12 books. I don't feel it would be fair to sign up for urth.net and then take over the discussion with a group of people who were reading the books from start to finish.

This way, we have something that the members of urth.net can take part in if they want (I contacted the people who run it and tried to make an announcement, but it failed so I'm checking into why I couldn't post to the group) but the e-mail list doesn't HAVE to feel like they should take part. They can continue their ongoing conversation about the book and we can have our book club.

This isn't a replacement of the amazing things they've done at urth.net, but rather an enhancement of it or outgrowth of it.
Fred Coppersmith
14.  FCoppersmith
VIEW ALL BY · Monday January 12, 2009 11:24am EST · amended on Monday January 12, 2009 11:25am EST
This is oh so very tempting. I read The Shadow of the Torturer just a few years ago, recently enough that I think I can make do without re-reading it (yet), and I own a copy of The Claw of the Conciliator. I'm not sure how much I'd be able to join in the discussion, but it wouldn't hurt to have an excuse to continue reading some Gene Wolfe.

Not that one should need an excuse, but it is nice to have the added impetus.
Jon Evans
15.  rezendi
VIEW ALL BY · Monday January 12, 2009 11:41am EST
Man, I would so love to join this, but my schedule does not allow (writing 'til February, then travelling 'til mid-March, both of which tend to impinge on schedule reading.)
Damien G. Walter
16.  Bill Ward
Monday January 12, 2009 01:04pm EST
This is so tempting, as I think I'm personally do for a reread of all twelve. Don't know how I can fit that in with my schedule, but I'll follow the conversation over there regardless.

A great idea.
Sol Foster
17.  colomon
VIEW ALL BY · Monday January 12, 2009 01:24pm EST
Just read the first two for the first time last month, so count me in and excited!

(Though now that I think about it, blowing through them all in a single year seems a little wasteful, if they are all as good as the first two...)
Damien G. Walter
18.  egregory
Monday January 12, 2009 03:14pm EST
I'm on "Citadel of the Autarch" at the moment. So: sounds good!
Justin Adair
19.  Hobbyns
VIEW ALL BY · Monday January 12, 2009 03:35pm EST
I tried to read The Shadow of the Torturer as a boy, and it went waaaay over my head. I remembered being deeply intrigued by all of the mysteries of the book, sensing that there was much beyond my understanding, but couldn't apply myself appropriately.

I freely admit it was probably a bad idea back then to go from reading the Chronicles of Narnia to the Book of the New Sun, but I've wanted to go back to the series ever since, especially after reading the Wizard Knight books a few years ago.

Now to find the time to fit 12 densely written books into my already overloaded reading list. If I can't get to it, I'll still follow the book club conversation with interest.
Jonathan Rock
20.  jonathanerock
VIEW ALL BY · Monday January 12, 2009 09:21pm EST
Yo,

I read these last year. I am now In Green's Jungles. But there is so dang much in this cycle and I look forward to voyaging with Severian, Silk and Horn with you all over again.
Samantha Brandt
21.  Talia
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday January 13, 2009 08:40am EST
I've never read any Gene Wolfe, but maybe I'll take a look.
Kevin Maroney
22.  womzilla
VIEW ALL BY · Thursday January 15, 2009 12:07pm EST
You could have held this on urth.net with e-mails all marked with a distinctive header (e.g., 'Sun Book Club' or [SBC]).

But that's just two of my prejudices speaking: a dislike of web-based discussion groups and a desire to consolidate discussions into existing forums. Not everyone shares my first objection, and there are problems with the second (e.g., discussion getting swamped by the existing community).

But I do recommend the URTH archives for anyone interested in Wolfean matters. And I've poked my head in on the web board even though I haven't re-read BOTNS in about a decade.
Damien G. Walter
23.  Bluejack
Sunday January 18, 2009 01:35pm EST
I'm in!
POST A COMMENT Name: Email Address: Comment (bbCode allowed):