Fri
Mar 5 2010 2:11pm
The Great Comics Read-Along: Intro

Hi there! Welcome to a new series on Tor.com. My name is Brit Mandelo and in this space every Friday we will be reading comics together. Specifically, comics that would fall under the umbrella of “speculative fiction,” like Warren Ellis’s Transmetropolitan or Bill Willingham’s Fables. For everyone who already loves them: this is the perfect time to re-read those series that you loved and haven’t had a chance to revisit in a while. For the readers who’ve only wondered about some of this stuff: I promise, you’ll have a good time. The world of SFF is so much broader than just prose or poetry. Comics can make you laugh, cry, rage and maybe put back a drink or two when you’re done. And the art! Oh, the art.

As for the particulars, the schedule will alternate between single-volume and series readings to keep things fresh. The starting series will be Transmetropolitan, mostly because it was the first comic that convinced me I might be a fan. After that, I have a list, but I’d like to hear from you what comics you think would be worth reading together. For now I’d like to stick with creator-owned series but branching out to a little company-owned (aka-Marvel & DC universe) stuff for some particularly good storytelling is possible. Each post will be a mix of summary, commentary, hey-look-at-that-in-the-background, and discussion. Disagree with me, disagree amongst yourselves, but above all, participation is awesome. It’s cool if all you have to say is “I really love this volume.” (You may recognize this format from the LotR or Wheel of Time read-alongs.)

The current list I have in mind is this—Transmetropolitan, Preacher, Fables, Y the Last Man, V for Vendetta, book tie-ins like The Dresden Files: Welcome to the Jungle or Mercy Thompson: Homecoming, The Boys, Death, Mouse Guard… and what else? Thrill me, here. I love finding new writers. (I’ve intentionally skipped Sandman because someone else has that covered already and Watchmen because of the large amount of coverage when the movie came out.)

If you’d like to hear a little about me before we embark on this journey, here are the highlights—I live in Louisville, Kentucky and attend the university here. I’m a bookseller for Waldenbooks and I really, really love my job. I have big geeky love for mythology, art and music, among other things (obviously, comics). I’m a writer working toward getting a book signed. Aside from this comic read-along series, I’ll also be writing about queer speculative fiction here on Tor.com. You can find me on Twitter as @BritMandelo and on Livejournal under the same name.

Enough about me. Tell me about what else you’d like to see included here in the read-alongs. There are plenty of weeks in a year and plenty of comics to fill them! See you same time next week for Transmetropolitan v. 1: Back on the Street. Come ready to party, Ellis style.


Index | Transmetropolitan Vol 1: Back on the Street »


Transmetropolitan Reread: index | next ›
45 comments
Jer Brown
1. designguybrown
Faves from my bookshelf that may provoke interesting chat:
Pax Romana
We3
Sky Doll
Wanted
DMZ
Pride of Baghdad
Surrogates
Winterworld
Dark Tower

.. and hoping to check out...
Ender's Game
Neverwhere
Planetes
Ramayan 3392 ad

worth it?
Jer Brown
2. designguybrown
Also, would like to know what people think of European Spec comics/ graphic novels - seem very idea-packed.
David Goldfarb
3. David_Goldfarb
Scott McCloud's Zot! and Carla Speed McNeil's Finder spring instantly to mind as two of my favorites, along with Larry Marder's Tales of the Beanworld. There's also Phil and Kaja Foglio's Hugo-winning Girl Genius, and if you're not allergic to manga, Hayao Miyazaki's Nausicaa of the Valley of Wind.
Russell Heilling
4. Russell Heilling
While I was reading Sandman and Preacher the other title I would wait for eagerly each month was Grant Morrison's "Invisibles". His run on "Doom Patrol" would also be a good pick...
Tim Nolan
5. Dr_Fidelius
Come ready to party, Ellis style.

Oh god. Are you sure?
Pablo Defendini
6. pablodefendini
I'll bring the contraband, high-potency designer drugs and the bowel disruptor. Ellis FTMFW.
James Goetsch
7. Jedikalos
Sounds like a good way to get to know these hitherto unread (by me) texts. I have read all the Sandman by Gaiman, though (just none of those you list). Fun!
Russell Heilling
8. mirana
Finder, Bone, Hellboy...

I'm guess you're cutting out anything Asian, European or Web as you are DC/Marvel? Probably best in the beginning (because they're so vast), but definitely consider those offerings in the future.
Alex Brown
9. Milo1313
Much excited about this, especially for read-alongs with Hellboy, Y: The Last Man, and Preacher, but what the hell happened to the read-along for Sandman? We got 1 entry and then that was it. Is anyone actually going to continue with that?
Russell Heilling
10. AimeeK
How about Promethea? I really enjoyed that one.
Estara Swanberg
11. Estara
Since we're sticking to US-Eurocentric comics, I'm seconding Carla Speed McNeill's Finder series and throwing Linda Medley's Castle Waiting into the pot, as well as Ursula Vernon's Digger.
Pablo Defendini
12. pablodefendini
@Milo1313

Teresa Nielsen Hayden will continue with the re-read, fear not. Exploratory trips into the Dreaming are expensive and time-consuming—passage is not cheap. Last we heard from her she was heading into Lucien's library for a bout of research... on second thought, it may be a while yet.
Brit Mandelo
13. BritMandelo
@designguybrown

Ah, yes, DMZ! Copying down the list, some of which I need to check out.

@David_Golfarb

I am not allergic to manga. I'm just hard to impress. *g* I'll add those to the list. (How did I not remember Girl Genius?)

@Russell Heilling

Added.

@Dr_Fidelius @pablodefendidi

I mean, we can try it. I've got some whiskey in the freezer for ready-grabbing.

@Jedikalos

Oh, I promise, it'll be awesome. I have a special love for Transmetropolitan.

@mirana

Actually, no, I'm only cutting universe-based stuff for reader ease. Breaking into the density of the DC/Marvel stuff is reaaaally hard for beginner comics readers a lot of the time. I'm open to Asian/Euro/etc. stuff so long as readers can find them easily.

@AimeeK @Estara

Stuff added!
Russell Heilling
14. Steevo
How about Mike Carey's Lucifer or 100 Bullets by Brian Azzarello. And you can never go wrong with Bone (Jeff Smith), Powers (Brian Michael Bendis), or Sin City (Frank Miller). There are a bunch more I'm sure, but I'm lazy and away from my collection.


Oh...someone mentioned Bone...well, that's two votes for Bone then.
Alex Brown
15. Milo1313
pablodefendini @ 12: Phew! Although 5 months seems like a long time for it, but I'm still excited.

In the meantime, also forgot to add Ex Machina...such a great series as well. Oh, and the Swamp Thing series by Moore/Gaiman/et al would be a great re-read.
Russell Heilling
17. Argento
Yayyyy grats on your first column Brit :> Seconding Bone by the way. The art style at first might be a turnoff, but the story is fantastic.
Brit Mandelo
18. BritMandelo
@Steevo

How could I forget Mike Carey! Argh! (I'm enjoying "Unwritten" though it's still so new.)

@Milo1313

Oh, Swamp Thing. Yes, yes, definitely Swamp Thing.

@cybernetic_nomad

Will check out.

@Argento

Oh, you. *g* I have no idea how I didn't think of Bone, either. It's definitely added to the list.
Russell Heilling
19. vcmw
Glancing at my shelves for things not mentioned yet:
Courtney Crumrin by Ted Naifeh? I think it does a really good job with its folklore/fairy tale motifs, and the art is charming and occasionally grotesque - a good combo.

Transmetropolitan, Preacher, and Fables are probably among my all time favorites, so I'll be looking forward to that - and agree with others that Bone is probably central.

There's a ton of great stuff that came out that was more-or-less for kids recently - Jellaby stood out for me.
Russell Heilling
20. Stefan Jones
You want a challenge?

Jimmy Corrigan: The Smartest Boy on Earth
Josh Matthews
21. jdm
Ed Brubaker's Sleeper, Warren Ellis' Desolation Jones, also Global Frequency. Maybe Constantine?
Russell Heilling
22. Doug M.
21 comments, nearly 100 recommendations, and not one person has mentioned Starstruck.

Starstruck.

Starstruck.

Starstruck, by Mike Kaluta and Elaine Lee. Not only the best comic space opera ever, but one of the best space operas ever.

It's obscure but not /that/ obscure -- any good comic should should have it.

Here's a sample review:

http://www.comicsbulletin.com/reviews/125036829941402.htm


Doug M.
Pasi Kallinen
23. paxed
Anything by Jean Giraud (aka Moebius), though I've got a soft spot for The Airtight Garage and The Silver Surfer special.

Enki Bilal's Nikopol Trilogy


(Oh, the Art!)
Sumana Harihareswara
24. brainwane
Anything by Brian K. Vaughan (Ex Machina, Y, etc.), Runaways, She-Hulk, DMZ, Fables.
Brit Mandelo
25. BritMandelo
@vcmw @Stefan Jones @jdm @Doug M.@paxed @brainwane

All added to the list. I'll try and get a hold of them!
Russell Heilling
26. ctkierst
I second/third the Willingham and the Vaughan. I'd also add "Midnight Nation", "Runaways", "Locke and Key", "Rising Stars", "Supreme Power", "The Book of Lost Souls" (yes, I like JMS), Stangers in Paradise. I'm still trying to scrub some of the images from Preacher out of my head, though some of it was brilliant. How about Colleen Doran's "A Distant Soil"? The Authority and Planetary are fun...
Josh Storey
27. Soless
Seconding calls for "Runaways," "Locke & Key," "Unwritten," "Bone," and "Hellboy."

Also, Douglas Rushkoff's "Testament" has some interesting things going on not only in the text but also the panels and gutters between.
Russell Heilling
28. TheGloop
I love Tranmetropolitan way more than a sweet little children's librarian should. It rocks twelve kinds of awesome. Just finished reading Ignition City (also by Ellis) and it is pretty cool also.
Brit Mandelo
29. BritMandelo
@ctkierst @Soless

Added!

@TheGloop

I'm a huge Ellis fan. I like the way that man talks. *g* I haven't started Ignition City yet, but I'm going mad for more of Doktor Sleepless.
JP Ikäheimonen
30. Oldtribe
Some of my favorites that have not yet been mentioned:

Tank Girl
Adele Blanc-Sec
the Dungeon series
Wesley Osam
31. Wesley
Along with Carla Speed McNeill's Finder, some of the best science fiction comics out there are the stories Dash Shaw has published in MOME. He's also drawn an SF graphic novel, Bodyworld.

On the fantasy side, I'd love to see the site introduce readers to Jim Woodring's Frank stories, as well as the Hernandez brothers' Love and Rockets (which is often realism, but takes frequent side trips into magic realism).

There's a lot of great SF work out there on the "alternative" shelves.
Russell Heilling
32. ctkierst
Oh, how about Kurt Busiek's Astro City? Moore's Top 10? I would have recommended Starstruck, but it's actually rather hard to find. I only ever managed to find a couple of issues. I've heard good things of Bone, and I really liked Mignola's Hellboy. The Rocketeer is nicely self-contained, and has just been republished. Lucifer was interesting, as was 100 Bullets, though I'd only borrowed a middle trade paperback from a friend on the latter, so I was rather lost.

Yeah, Moore's Swamp Thing is also good, though disturbing in spots. What about that brilliant run on Animal Man (Davis?)?
Brit Mandelo
33. BritMandelo
@Oldtribe

Added.

@Wesley

I've had almost as many requests for Finder as I've had for Bone, so I definitely will be checking it out. Added the others, too.

@ctkierst

I hadn't thought about 100 Bullets. I read the first trade of that a while back, liked it, and never found more. I'll have to start searching.
Teresa Jusino
34. TeresaJusino
So excited about this, as I LOVE Transmet and comics in general!

I agree that We3 should be on this list, as well as anything by Brian K. Vaughan. Also:

AIR (G. Willow Wilson)
Incognito (Ed Brubaker)
Orbiter (Warren Ellis)

That's what I've got off the top of my head that hasn't already been mentioned, but if I think of more, I'll let you know! :)
Brit Mandelo
35. BritMandelo
@TeresaJusino

I have Incognito on my to-read pile right now, actually! I'm guessing the recommendation means it's good. *g* The cover was hard to resist.
Teresa Jusino
36. TeresaJusino
@BritMandelo - yes! I enjoyed Incognito very much. The art is great, the story is really interesting, and I also recommended it as an example of a recent sci-fi comic.
Martin Wisse
37. Martin_Wisse
Re eurocomix of interest to sf/f fans:

The long running French sf comic Valerian should be required reading, if only for the way in which Christin and Mezieres solve the problem of their outdated future setting (global flooding in 1986 and New York under Water) when it became urgent. For those who've seen the Fifth Element, much of the decor may seem familiar, as Mezieres was responsible for much of said film's look (and George Lucas has been accused of being a bit too familiar with his work as well)

Christin also worked with Enki Bilal, already mentioned, on three sf fables, collected in English in Townscapes a few years ago. Bilal himself has also done much sf on his own, with the Nikopol trilogy as a highlight, though that's very French..

There's also the Jean Claude Forest/Paul Gillon production "Les Naufrages Du Temps", a Vancian far future romp, with lots of nudity too, something Gillon does a lot in his work.

Also of interest: the Marvano adaptations of Haldeman's the Forever War and To Live Forever.
Russell Heilling
38. rDjSb
How about Miracleman?
Russell Heilling
39. ostermei
Another vote for Ex Machina.

Matt Fraction's "Casanova" (although it seems to be on indefinite hiatus :(
Russell Heilling
41. psychicscubadiver
Hey Brit, finally remembered. I know the list of creater comics is frighteningly, wonderfully huge, but if you're ever looking to break into the Marvel universe I have a suggestion: 'Marvel 1602' a one-shot, recently out in trade paperback. It's got good writing (Neil Gaiman) and it introduces almost all of Marvel's major characters (changed somewhat to fit the time period, 1602). Some of the minor characters and references might slide past beginners but I'd still say it's the best starting point.
Brit Mandelo
42. BritMandelo
@psychicscubadiver

Why, hello there, friend! Yeah, I do own 1602. Hadn't thought of that.
Russell Heilling
43. Edward Khil
@Milo1313 and @Pablodefendini,

AND dozens of others, I'm sure:

Will someone please tug Teresa Nielson Hayden on the sleeve and ask her to provide an explanation as to why she started a re-read of Sandman and then failed to make another post or even reply to the comments from the original post for FIVE MONTHS (since September 14)!

Better yet, will someone with more consideration and basic courtesy start a new re-read? Ms. Hayden has apparently hijacked the discussion (after a very interesting first post).

Ms. Hayden: Kate Nepveu has been diligent in her efforts to maintain the momentum of her Lord of the Rings re-read here on Tor, even though she's been up every night with a newborn child.

In short, what's your excuse?

I feel cheated by that farce of a re-read. And I'm sure I'm not the only one.

Poor "The Knife" was so frustrated that he(she?) tried to continue the re-read in the comments of the original post.

Tor: This is ridiculous. Please MAKE Ms. Hayden get off the pot, and let's get a good Sandman re-read going here on The Great Comics Re-Along, after Transmetropolitan.

@Milo1313, how can you still be excited by Ms. Hayden's re-read, FIVE MONTHS LATER?

THIS IS FREAKING RIDICULOUS!
Russell Heilling
44. t0kengirl
Definately Lucifer - I always fall in love with everything by Mike Carey.

League of Extroridnary Gentlemen anyone?
x x
45. xxxxx
Hi Brit,
was thinking The Invisibles (Grant Morrison)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Invisibles
would make a great read-along, if that is possilbe at all.
Then again, with Anarchy for the Masses,
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Anarchy-Masses-Disinformation-Guide-Invisibles/dp/0971394229
there is kind of a read-along out there already, but it doesnt really explain much. And with a novel like I it would be good to get someones elses opinion :)

m

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment