Sat
Feb 7 2009 10:54am

Dealing with Dragons: gender and sexuality in manga

Ranma 1/2

Winner for best New York Comic Con panel title of the weekend definitely goes to yesterday’s “Are you there, God? It’s me, Manga.” The panel was a presentation by two young adult librarians from the Brooklyn Public Library, Lisa Goldstein and Molly Phelan. They discussed the ways in which manga is fundamentally part of the broader spectrum of young adult literature and is equally valuable to teen readers.

Like the best young adult literature, manga deals with themes of identity and selfhood in a powerful, accessible way. I hadn’t realized the extent to which girls dominated the manga market—75% of manga readers are teen girls. Shojo, or manga targeted to teen girls under the age of 18, confronts issues of power (and powerlessness), gender roles and expectations, and ambivalence about sexuality. Manga is a safe space to discuss a sandbox of potentially problematic ideas—gender dysphoria, homo- or bisexuality, and one’s place within communities.

As someone who is not a huge manga reader, this got me wondering about a whole host of issues. Is other young adult fiction (prose) as open about these issues? I can’t think of a single example that wasn’t some flat-out afterschool special about sexuality (and those books were huge turn-offs for me). Does the graphic aspect of manga change the way in which we approach the characters and their feelings? It makes it more immediate, for sure, but are we then more sympathetic? Does sexuality seem more normal if we see it right in front of us? Manga seems to be uniquely positioned as a safe space for these ideas, but will that change if it becomes more widely available and popular?

Goldstein and Phelan also discussed shonen-ai, or “boys’ love” manga, about homosexual male couples. Shonen-ai is pure romance—it’s utterly fantastic, escapist, and lacks any accountability or real world consequences. In shonen-ai there is no possibility of marriage, and no worry about traditional expectations. The characters aren’t men, they’re boys; they’re androgynous. It allows female readers to experience sexuality without the trappings of heterosexual power dynamics or inherent assumptions about roles. While a lot of boys’ love manga reflects heterosexual stereotypes (one “dominant” partner and one “submissive” partner), the girl can project herself to either—or both.

I don’t think this dynamic would work if both characters were girls. As boys, they don’t begin in a position of powerlessness, and they’re granted a freedom of agency that I don’t think girls would have. As a kid and a young adult, I never identified with girls in novels. Girls in novels were usually weaker, not as motivated, and less generally interesting. I always identified with the boys, possibly because they felt more fleshed out as people—their problems were more universal and their plights more sympathetic. And I never, ever, came across a story that involved gay or even remotely homosexual characters. What a huge difference there is now.

One point Ms. Goldstein and Ms. Phelan emphasized was that shonen-ai is almost entirely drama (and melodrama) of unrequited love/ fulfilled love. There is no focus on coming to terms with one’s sexuality, or what the consequences are. There is no acceptance that they are “gay” in the sense that they accept, or reject, the trappings of that identity and its implications. The issue is never homosexuality itself—the issue is passionate love.

The librarians closed by looking towards the future, and wondering how these books will shape the current generation. Does this kind of manga make kids more tolerant of others? Will they be more willing to accept those who don’t adhere to traditional sexes or sexualities as “normal”? Will it create more opportunities for dialogue? Or at the end of the day is it all just a fantasy, Shakespeare-style, that doesn’t actually change anything in the end?

8 comments
Cassandra Phillips-Sears
1. cphillips-sears
There isn't a publicly-available transcript of this session specifically, is there?
Torie Atkinson
2. Torie
@ 1 cphillips-sears

I wish there were! I haven't been able to find one, but maybe they'll post it online after the convention.
Heather Massey
3. sfrgalaxy
Sounds like that was a great panel. Thanks for the overview, Torie!
AgentRamona
4. AgentRamona
There is plenty of YA fiction dealing with gender issues. For the comic book reader I might start with Hero by Terry Moore, but Debbie Harry Sings in French (Megan Brothers) is another favorite of mine right now.
Torie Atkinson
5. Torie
@ 4

Interesting! Those are both from the last few years, though. I wonder if a growing openness about these issues is at all related to the increasing availability (and interest in) manga? Or maybe, rather than one being the impetus for the other, maybe they're both just extensions of the same cultural shift?
AgentRamona
6. Megan Honig
YA fiction has changed a lot in the past 10 years, and there are definitely YA titles that deal with gender and sexuality with nuance, flexibility, and some amount of levity (Freak Show by James St. James comes to mind, among many others).

I agree with the presenters, though, that sometimes teens want to read about a world in which gender and sexuality are not problems or obstacles, period, and while there are YA novels where this is true, there are many more examples of wacky gender fluidity! or fluffy romance! in manga.
AgentRamona
8. hapax
David Levithan's BOY MEETS BOY is a wonderful lighthearted comedy where gender and sexuality is open and accepted and not at all an issue.

And while it's not as common as shonen-ai, there is also plenty of light "safe" teen-oriented yuri (girl-girl romance) manga as well. KASHIMASHI comes to mind as one of the most popular.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment