Log In Using
Facebook
Twitter
Google

Your tor.com Acct
Thu
Jul 24 2008 7:56pm
Finding the Doctor

In an earlier post, Tor.com’s Pablo Defendini covered a Q&A with Steven Moffat from San Diego Comic Con. [And more of that interview will be posted shortly.] Starting with series five, Moffat, who wrote several of the most memorable episodes of the BBC's Doctor Who revival, including “The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances” and "The Girl in the Fireplace" (both of which won Hugo Awards) and the very scary “Blink,” will take over as showrunner. The fourth season recently ended.

When I was a little kid I’d watch Tom Baker’s Fourth Doctor Who on PBS with my Dad. For decades I carried around in my head images of the Doctor’s wild curly hair and long scarf, K-9 and the TARDIS. None of the plots stuck with me although I remember being scared of Daleks and I always had a distinct memory of Sarah Jane being very put out because the Doctor returned her to earth in the wrong place.  

After many years, and more Doctors that I didn’t watch, Russell T. Davies -- whose name I either curse or speak with reverence -- revived the franchise with Chris Eccleston as the Ninth Doctor. I resisted. At that point I still referred to the TARDIS as a “phone booth” and had a lot of other stuff to watch. I resisted.

When I finally watched, it took eight minutes into the first episode and I was gone, completely hooked.

The show took strongly enough with me that when Nine changed to Ten, it felt wrong, all wrong. What had they done with my Doctor? And if anything should happen to Ten and we get an Eleven, I’ll probably say the same thing (it may not hurt quite as much; they say you never really let go of your first Doctor). Every companion that comes along, I think is the best one, until the next one. “Who was the best companion?” is about an unanswerable as “who was the best Doctor?”

According to epguides.com, the series started November 23, 1963 and ran almost every year (skipping a few years) until 1989. New Who started up in March of 2005. That’s a lot of backlog to catch up on, even considering a number of the earliest episodes are lost. But the more deeply I get pulled in to New Who the more curious I am about the history.

For now I’m perfectly content (aside from the occasional rant) with my New School Who. Doctor Who, as a character and an idea and a franchise, is fantastic. It veers between cheesy plots and superb science fiction, mixed with convincing drama, humor and sadness (sometimes it does it all of that at the same time; did you hear that the TARDIS can do your laundry, too?) The ideas and emotions hit a universal note. I’d recommend it to people who have a heartbeat.

[Image by Andrew Wong, licensed under Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike 2.5. Full image details here.]

14 comments
Stephanie Chaplin
1. Plate
Tom Baker was the fourth, not the fifth doctor.
Sterling Anderson
2. sterling
I have a very similar experience. I used to watch Doctor Who on PBS as well. I would really like to go back and watch the old episodes, but the idea of doing that just seems so daunting.

I'm now fully hooked into the new series and cannot wait for new episodes. I'm going to try and get my wife into it by starting over and watching them with her. I'm even thinking of looking into The Sarah Jane Adventures with my two older kids.

Doctor Who is the science fiction television I have had the pleasure to watch in years.
Constance Cochran
3. ccochran
Plate: I knew that! I swear I did.

sterling: It's the same for me. The earlier stuff interests me but there's a lot of it. Sarah Jane Adventures is very good -- slow warmup but stay with it. The characters develop nicely and Elisabeth Sladen is just terrific as SJ.
akabrady
4. akabrady
I always thought the Daleks did the laundry?

Is it just me or do they look like washing machines with things sticking out?
Kevin Connolly
5. K.V.C-TOR
For Fans of the new Who, you really don't need all the history since RTD tossed 99% of it out the window.
akabrady
6. Troylis
I got hooked on the Tom Baker series on PBS in the late 80s', after reading Marvel reprints of the British Dr. Who comic (featuring my first dose of Dave Gibbons art). For me, the first Doctor is the Fourth :)

That being said, I think I got a better sense of the history of Dr. Who from reading some of the novel adaptations of classic storylines, and from a Dr. Who RPG manual.

Even with all my Who love, most of the episodes can be a chore to sit through, and the "backstory" was cobbled together by dozens of writers over decades with little effort spent on internal logic or consistency. The best thing to do is not worry about the "history" and instead get a handle on the "flavour" of the series. A sampling of some of the best storylines from a rental place should do that for you.
Rob Hansen
7. RobHansen
I started watching Doctor Who with the very first broadcast on 23rd November 1963, the day after JFK was shot, and followed it faithfully until the early 1980s, when increasingly poor scripts and shoddy effects made me lose interest. New Who has seriously revived my love of the show and I've been buying up a lot of DVDs of the old stuff and enjoying them greatly. However, the idea that there's a lot of backstory you need to catch up on is misleading. Most of the old stories were standalones that had no great effect on the mythology of the show. Quite a few of them are also unwatchable, though others still hold up. DVDs I've bought and enjoyed featuring older Doctors that I would personally recommend are:

William Hartnell: Dalek Invasion of Earth
Patrick Troughton: The Invasion:
Jon Pertwee: Inferno
Tom Baker: City of Death
Paul Weimer
8. PrinceJvstin
Those are good choices for the first four Doctors.

Rounding out the older Doctors:

Peter Davison:Earthshock. Matthew Waterhouse's maligned Adric is finally used in a good way...only to see him fall.
Colin Baker: He leaves me cold. If you must see an episode with him, Revelation of the Daleks has strong minor characters, The Two Doctors (despite its weaknesses) brings back Troughton and Hines.
Sylvester McCoy: I think The Curse of Fenric best showcases his acting ability and what his incarnation was "all about".
Wesley Osam
9. Wesley
The two versions of Doctor Who are an interesting contrast. The new series is both better and worse than the original. In some ways it's smarter, in some ways dumber, and at different times it's been much more and much less adult.

For me the best run of Doctor Who was the series of novels published by Virgin Books under the New Adventures title. Unfortunately these are out of print, probably permanently, but you can find a few (not all of them among the best) on the BBC's website, including the original version of Human Nature.

The DVDs I'd suggest for each Doctor would be:

1: The Aztecs
2: The Mind Robber
3: Inferno
4: The Robots of Death and City of Death (Tom Baker's era went through two distinct styles, and if one leaves you cold you may like the other.)
5: The Caves of Androzani
6: Vengeance on Varos
7: Remembrance of the Daleks
Lon Braidwood
10. daDiceGuy
This new version of Dr Who has my wife and her best friend Lisa hooked and they loathed the old Dr Who.
Angela Korra'ti
11. annathepiper
I'd always half-watched the classic Doctor over the shoulders of my partner and housemate, both of whom have been Whovians for a very long time.

But it took the Ninth Doctor to officially pull me into the fandom--and, like you, I was hugely disconcerted by the shift from Nine to Ten. Now David Tennant has well and thoroughly charmed me into making him my favorite Doctor, though I still periodically see Nine's episodes and remember that I liked him very much, but for different reasons.

Plus, I've gone back and watched classic Who with a new appreciation. My aforementioned housemate has a lot of Dalek episodes on tape, and going through those gave me a nice high-level overview of the various Doctors, with the exception of Two.

I very, very much liked Genesis of the Daleks, and was struck by mannerisms of Tom Baker's that seem to have echoes in Tennant's portrayal. Tennant may claim that Five's really "his" Doctor, but I think Baker influenced him, too. ;)

Also: I heartily second RobHansen's recommendation of The Invasion. It's a rebuilt Two episode, filled in with bits of animation, but they did the job quite nicely. Be sure to watch the extras, because there's a hugely giggleworthy bit in them about writing on the wall in one scene.
Ben H
12. dripgrind
Thanks for this timely and insightful look at a little-known programme!
paul wallich
13. paulw
Anyone want to tackle NewWho:OldWho :: NewBSG:OldBSG?

I think the thing that distinguishes both updates is their earnestness. Sometimes their bleeping scenery-chewing annoying shut-the-f-up-already earnestness. Which is kinda odd in a world of postmillennial irony and cynicism, or perhaps not. (After all, compared to post-imperial britain everybody else is pretty much pikers at those games.)
Rob Hansen
14. RobHansen
annathepiper: The problem with the Troughton era is that so much of it is missing. The Invasion is the best of what's available on DVD but it's not the best of his period. Like most people who remember seeing it when it aired, I have strong and positive memories of The Web of Fear, which put Yeti in the tunnels of the London Underground, and would love to see it again. Sadly, only a single episode from this tale still exists, which is also true of Evil of the Daleks, another great story. And, of course, Troughton's other meeting with the malevolent pepperpots, Power of the Daleks, is missing in its entirety, as is Fury From the Deep. Those are the four tales whose loss I regret the most.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment