Five Books Set in a Fantastical America

When I was a kid, my very favorite books were fantasy that had one foot in the real world—think Harry Potter, think Shadowhunters, think His Dark Materials, think American Gods, think Daughter of Smoke and Bone. In these stories, there was magic here—accessible through secret doorways or via enchanted trains or right in front of you, if you happened to get the glamour lifted. I think I loved these stories so much because they made me feel like the world was bigger than what I could see. Like magic might be out there for me, if I looked hard enough.

Even though it’s looking less and less likely that I’ll get that letter or find that doorway, I’m still obsessed with these kinds of stories—books that make me think for a second: maybe, just maybe. And today’s authors are weaving magic into our society in ever more imaginative, surprising, and inclusive ways. Read on if you want that feeling too—that glimmer of doubt that what you see is all there is; that moment of wondering whether magic will be just around the next corner.


The Diviners by Libba Bray

The Roaring Twenties are in full swing, and seventeen-year-old Evie O-Neill’s dreams are full of flapper dresses and glamorous parties. She has never given much thought to her ability to read people’s history by touching their possessions. But when an embarrassing hometown scandal obligates her to pull up roots and relocate from Ohio to NYC, she quickly becomes embroiled in the otherworldly. Her uncle, who runs a museum of the occult in Manhattan, is tasked with solving a series of terrifying and seemingly supernaturally tinged murders popping up throughout the city; and Evie wonders if she can help. A range of equally vividly drawn, magically gifted teens from all corners of the city round out the cast. There’s tons of fascinating period detail, and the dread feeling that the murderer is circling closer and closer to our heroes makes the six hundred pages race by. As a bonus, you’ll learn a lot of fun twenties lingo that will ab-so-tute-ly sneak its way into your everyday conversation.


The Devouring Gray by Christine Lynn Herman

Set in the fictional but very, very real-seeming upstate small town of Four Paths, NY, The Devouring Gray starts out following Violet Saunders, who moves with her mother to Four Paths after the death of her sister. While creeped out by the town—which Herman drenches in claustrophobic atmosphere, creeping fog, and tree branches scratching at windows—Violet comes to understand she is inextricably tied to Four Paths’ history, alongside her peers Justin, May, Harper, and Isaac, all of whom are descended from the town’s mysterious founders. And something is amiss in the woods. Something is lurking among the trees, and it’s hungry. The teens must figure out how to defeat that ancient evil while dealing with their own traumas and complicated relationships with each other, their families, and the town. Herman situates her tormented, lovable ensemble cast amidst a backdrop of mounting dread behind a picturesque facade, and it all adds up to a tale that is equal parts delicious and unsettling.


Reverie by Ryan La Sala

Reverie is set in a middle-class industrial town in modern-day central Connecticut. Yet it feels a little bit misleading to say that, because in the pages of La Sala’s wildly imaginative debut, we will also encounter myriad other worlds–pocket worlds, dream worlds–which pose the very real risk of overtaking the aforementioned town. When the curtain rises on Reverie, Kane Montgomery’s life is fractured in a thousand different ways. He recently suffered a car accident that left him with strange scars and on the radar of the local police department, but he can’t tell them anything because he doesn’t remember the accident… or the months preceding it. He is isolated by his lack of memories, the homophobic bullying he’s encountered at school. And the people who claim to be his best friends are telling him wild, incredible stories about evil drag queens and dreams that come to life—and that he is instrumental to stopping the Reveries from overtaking reality. To be honest, this book is structured in such a fresh, unique way that I’m not sure I can describe it in a way that does it justice. Just go read it.


The Epic Crush of Genie Lo by F.C. Yee

In the pressure-cooker environment of a Bay Area prep school, high-achieving sixteen-year-old Genie Lo will do whatever it takes to get into Harvard. But her plans are disrupted when she discovers that she is the reincarnation of an ancient weapon belonging to the Monkey King of Chinese mythology; furthermore, the obnoxious but cute new boy at school, Quentin, is in fact the manifestation of Sun Wukong himself. Oh, and there’s been a jailbreak in hell. A host of terrifying demons have escaped, and Genie must quickly get a handle on her newfound powers in order to dispatch them back. Yet she can’t defer her day-to-day responsibilities just because she’s singlehandedly responsible for saving the world–a mood that will be familiar to anyone who’s ever lost sleep over college applications. In between learning her abilities and kicking demon butt, she has to keep her grades up, deal with friend and family drama, and navigate the push-pull chemistry she feels with Quentin. The pace is breakneck, and Genie’s fabulously dry, sarcastic humor keeps things from feeling too heavy, even when the fate of humanity hangs in the balance.


The Golem and the Jinni by Helene Wecker

With apologies for over-representing NYC historical fantasy on this list, I’ll just say that this is a magical city teeming with magical stories. In 1899, two new arrivals appear on the streets of Manhattan. They are even more out of place than their immigrant peers: Chava is a golem, created out of clay. Made to be the wife of a man who died on the voyage from Poland, she’s now alone and adrift in the city. Meanwhile, Ahmad is a fire-formed jinni from the Syrian desert, who is accidentally set free by a tinsmith after centuries trapped in a copper flask. They must both create a life for themselves in this new, strange world of tenements and narrow streets and elevated trains; learn how to exist in a society that wasn’t made for them, and try to appear human. Chava takes a job at a bakery and wonders where food goes when she eats it; Ahmad works for the tinsmith, making it a point of pride to learn the craft of metalworking rather than just using his innate fire magic to get the job done. They meet a range of fascinating people in their neighborhood, from wizards to rabbis to ice cream makers; and when their own paths cross, sparks will fly. In the hands of a lesser author, the parallels between immigrants entering America and supernatural beings entering the human world might have been heavy-handed. But Wecker’s subtly gorgeous prose means it works, becoming an intricate, epic love story with a mythic feel.


Originally published in March 2020.

Sara Holland is the author of the New York Times bestsellers Everless, Evermore, and most recently Havenfall. She grew up in small-town Minnesota, but also in the countless fictional worlds of books. She graduated from Wesleyan University and worked in a tea shop, a dentist’s office, and a state capitol building before heading to New York to work in publishing. These days, she can be found exploring the city’s bookstores or finding new ways to put caffeine in her bloodstream. Find her on Twitter @Sara__Holland.


Back to the top of the page

This post is closed for comments.

Our Privacy Notice has been updated to explain how we use cookies, which you accept by continuing to use this website. To withdraw your consent, see Your Choices.