“Speaking of livers,” the unicorn said, “Real magic can never be made by offering up someone else’s liver. You must tear out your own, and not expect to get it back. The true witches know that.”
—Peter S. Beagle, The Last Unicorn
* * *
My mother doesn’t know about the harpy.
My mother, Alice, is not my real mom. She’s my foster mother, and she doesn’t look anything like me. Or maybe I don’t look anything like her. Mama Alice is plump and soft and has skin like the skin of a plum, all shiny dark purple with the same kind of frosty brightness over it, like you could swipe it away with your thumb.
I’m sallow—Mama Alice says olive—and I have straight black hair and crooked teeth and no real chin, which is okay because I’ve already decided nobody’s ever going to kiss me.
I’ve also got lipodystrophy, which is a fancy doctor way of saying I’ve grown a fatty buffalo hump on my neck and over each shoulder blade from the antiretrovirals, and my butt and legs and cheeks are wasted like an old lady’s. My face looks like a dog’s muzzle, even though I still have all my teeth.
For now. I’m going to have to get the wisdom teeth pulled this year while I still get state assistance, because my birthday is in October and then I’ll be eighteen. If I start having problems with them after then, well forget about it.
There’s no way I’d be able to afford to get them fixed.
* * *
The harpy lives on the street, in the alley behind my building, where the dumpster and the winos live.
Tuesday December 08, 2009 09:54am EST
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 10:09am EST
The illustration is beautiful, too.
Tuesday December 08, 2009 11:22am EST
Tuesday December 08, 2009 11:22am EST
The story is very compelling. I was drawn into this girl's life, her thoughts, her musings. That made the ending all the more disappointing. I had hoped that she could soar, while life lasted; suicide isn't an answer.
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 11:25am EST
I hadn't thought it necessarily suicide--we don't know if she falls or is transformed.
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 11:26am EST
Thank you all so much for your comments.
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 11:33am EST
Tuesday December 08, 2009 12:12pm EST
(tho i turned poz as a male adult)
the viewpoint is nicely done.
the non-happy but non truely tragic ending ,merely grim and offering a choice, is the kind of thing i like about your writing.
i understand wanting more than just the safest course as well.
it's why i left sf and moved back to europe despite being poz.
i expect this will show up in some best of collection next year.
beautiful painting as well.
is this storie for a ya collection ?
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 12:30pm EST
Thank you for this!
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 12:37pm EST
I have no further plans for this story at this time, but of course I am open to developments.
Anita @9 I think so too. But I could be wrong.
Tuesday December 08, 2009 01:07pm EST
Tuesday December 08, 2009 01:22pm EST
I love the ending. I love that it's poised on the edge of as many possibilities as she is. I love the examination, the back and forth on that last page, the connection to the opening quote. It's just so GREAT.
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 01:56pm EST
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 07:24pm EST
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 07:48pm EST
And the picture is unutterably beautiful. If I had a decent printer I'd put it on my wall.
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 08:59pm EST
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 09:04pm EST
Amar @12, that's kind of how I felt about it too--I have always felt like you can choose the harpy's life or the mundane life, but you have to pick one--and they are both valid and valuable choices. It's the Peter Pan thing: you can be Pan, or you can be Wendy. There is no middle road. Alas.
TexAnne @15 ... how would one write a story about somebody with no agency?
And make it interesting?
Okay, now I feel challenged!
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 09:05pm EST
Tuesday December 08, 2009 10:33pm EST
Tuesday December 08, 2009 10:42pm EST
i have a special attraction to vultures, so the vulture-like quality of your harpy made it that much more special for me. the illustration is gorgeous.
soaring with those bronze wings...
Tuesday December 08, 2009 10:48pm EST
It owes an obvious family resemblance to "The White Donkey" by Le Guin, and there's also some of "The Women Men Don't See" by Tiptree, but it's all yours.
And it reminds me a little of "Grave of the Fireflies." I don't quite know why.
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday December 08, 2009 11:03pm EST
thereallinda @20, I had wanted to write a Harpy story for years, and then in 2007 I was privileged to meet a vulture and listen to a presentation about her, and I knew I was in business.
It only took me two more years to write the story after that.
Wednesday December 09, 2009 01:43am EST
I meant rather that I just never thought of it that way, though it's obvious in some ways--it also makes it a companion of sorts to "The White Donkey" to see it that way, because the girl doesn't go off with the unicorn in that story and in this one she does choose the harpy (I think--even that isn't entirely clear).
Oh, and I also think of "The Ring" by Isak Dinesen. Which may be online somewhere (it's quite a short story). That got me on a similar level.
Wednesday December 09, 2009 01:46am EST
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday December 09, 2009 06:17am EST
Wonderfully evocative artwork to go with it, too.
Anita @9: I do feel that she was somehow transformed at the end.
I'd argue that from the end point of the story, whether she chooses to jump/chooses magic/chooses the mundane life/slips and falls without making any choice at all, she will be transformed permanently.
Myself, I like the liminality of the way this story ends most of all, which is saying something, as I adore everything else about it, too.
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday December 09, 2009 03:21pm EST
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday December 09, 2009 06:28pm EST
I especially love the imagery of the sunlight transforming the harpy, and image of the sunrise that complete's Desiree's transformation at the end.
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday December 09, 2009 09:19pm EST
In the interest of polishing, there's a typo in the second paragraph of page five: "with" where "which" should be.
Wednesday December 09, 2009 10:21pm EST
For me the question is, does she need to become the harpy, or is she already the harpy.
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday December 09, 2009 10:28pm EST
Thursday December 10, 2009 05:21pm EST
Thursday December 10, 2009 05:21pm EST
Thursday December 10, 2009 05:30pm EST
Thursday December 10, 2009 05:37pm EST
But the one that sticks with me is, "What if the harpy lied?"
(And if so, what did it lie about?)
VIEW ALL BY · Friday December 11, 2009 12:02pm EST
Friday December 11, 2009 12:55pm EST
Beautiful, ugly, but always moving. Thank you!
Friday December 11, 2009 04:52pm EST
VIEW ALL BY · Friday December 11, 2009 11:09pm EST
Sunday December 13, 2009 04:12pm EST
great drawing too .
Tuesday December 15, 2009 03:19am EST
The illustration is gorgeous, too. Wow.
Oh - as for writing a story about a character with no agency, it's been done. It's called L'Etranger, by Albert Camus, and I would beg you not to add another book of the like to the canon. I'm not generally one for physically showing displeasure with a book, but I think I actually did throw that one across the room when I finished.
Tuesday December 15, 2009 05:22pm EST
Stunning and heartrending and achingly beautiful.
VIEW ALL BY · Sunday December 20, 2009 09:47pm EST
This is the kind of story Ellison talked about when he talked about Gerald Kersh and the haunted ones among us.
Very visceral, gripping, haunting. I would disagree with a choice to become the harpy, hunting for magic. Escaping into fantasy is an escape, a running away. Turning our back on reality doesn't mean it ceases to exist. It only means we can no longer affect it. It may still affect us.
Perhaps it is my insistence on reality and my reluctance to tear at my own liver that keeps from achieving what I'd like to. But it's the world I live in.
MKK
Tuesday December 22, 2009 04:53am EST
But the illustration is a typical marketeer's cop-out. The girl in the pic looks nothing like the physical description in the text. I hate that kind of gutless garbage.
Friday December 25, 2009 01:05am EST
A certain Lioness told me I would love your work; she is a fine judge.
You captured something that many of my patients would understand, that I can only glimpse and guess at. The ending was so... real... that's the best word I can find. When fiction feels real, you've hit something good.
Thank you for sipping at the cup of formula, and wrinkling your nose...
:-)
Tuesday December 29, 2009 01:14am EST
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday January 26, 2010 08:48am EST
Tuesday May 18, 2010 03:01pm EDT