The first time I read Teckla (1987) I hated it. Hated it. I like it now, but it took quite a lot of time for me to come around to it.
Teckla is set in the same fun fantasy world of Dragaera as the first two books of the series, but unlike the romps that are Jhereg and Yendi itâs a real downer. The animals the House of the Teckla are named after are mice, and the Teckla are the peasants and proletarians of the Empire. The book takes places chronologically immediately after Jhereg and it is about a proletarian uprising among the Teckla and Easterners (humans) of South Adrilankha. Itâs about ordinary people getting caught up with the Jhereg and the nasty side of assassinsâitâs no fun at all when itâs killing ordinary men and women who are threatening the profits of organized crime. Itâs also about the messy end of a relationship. Itâs about passing and being proud or ashamed of what you are.
What I hated about it was that it was grim and depressing and realistic in a way that turned the first two volumes inside out. Thatâs what I now appreciate about it. Teckla provides some necessary grounding, some chiaroscuro to the palette of Dragaera.
Spoilers.
Brust really uses his American-Hungarian heritage in these books. The Easterners, Fenarians, have Hungarian names and Hungarian culture, and he also uses Hungarian mythology and ideas about magic and witchcraft. But itâs not only that, itâs also the whole thing of being an immigrant in a wider culture, either getting trapped in a ghetto or getting out and despising those who donât. Vlad is a third-generation immigrant. His grandfather came from Fenario and lives in the ghetto, his father got out and aped the Dragaerans he lived among, and Vlad is uncomfortably caught between cultures. He knows he canât really be a Dragaeran, but he has a Jhereg title and thereâs the whole question of his soul that came up in Jhereg. Heâs uncomfortable with all this, and when Cawti gets involved with the revolutionary group he gets uncomfortable about that. There's a lot here that demonstrates understanding of what it is to live on the underside of a rich culture and the kind of thing people do about that.
Vlad spends a lot of this book literally hiding, and being frightened and miserable. As Yendi was the beginning of his marriage with Cawti, this is the end. This is a closely observed example of one of the ways a couple can split upâCawti is more interested in what sheâs doing in South Adrilankha than her marriage, and Vlad canât wonât and doesnât want to change. She has moved on and left him behind, and what he wants he canât haveâif the Cawti of his imagination was ever real, sheâs gone.
The Teckla of the title is probably Paresh, who tells Vlad his lifestory at length. This is one of the most interesting bits of the book, how Paresh, a peasant, became a sorcerer and a revolutionary. Vlad isnât solving a mystery here, as in the first two books. He tries to deal with a problem, and finds some answers, but the conclusion is at most only a deep breathâthe real conclusion is in Phoenix. (If there were any sense to the multiple volumes, Teckla and Phoenix would be bound together.)
None of Vladâs noble friends from the earlier books appear here. Morrolan tries to contact Vlad once, but we donât see any of them and theyâre barely mentioned. This is in keeping with the general Teckla tone of the book, and the general depressing tone too. It would be livened up with some of Morrolan and Alieraâs sparkling dialogue. Thereâs not much that sparkles here at all.
The peasants are unhappy, the urban poor are unhappy, theyâre getting organizedâthatâs really unusual for a fantasy world. It could be described as socialist fantasy, and it's certainly informed by a Marxist worldviewâwhich we learn in Phoenix is the view from the wrong world. That isn't how things work in Dragaera. (So clever he should watch out he doesn't cut himself.)
Teckla has a fascinating organizational structure. It's the usual seventeen chapters, but the book begins with a laundry list -- a list of clothes sent to the laundry with instructions about cleaning and mending them, and each chapter is headed with a little bit of that list like âremove bloodstains from cuff,â and in that chapter you see how the cuff got bloodstained, or how the cat-hairs got onto the cloak, and so on. Iâve never seen anything even remotely like that done before or since.
On to Taltos.
Jo Walton is a science fiction and fantasy writer. Sheâs published eight novels, most recently Half a Crown and Lifelode, and two poetry collections. She reads a lot, and blogs about it here regularly. She comes from Wales but lives in Montreal where the food and books are more varied.
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday November 24, 2009 11:36am EST
The way I understood it, the titles of the books refer not to actual characters, but to the House--each book answers the question, "what does it mean to be a [book title]?" So, in Jhereg, we (and Vlad) get a real sense of how it is to be a mobster; in Yendi, Vlad has to unravel a scheme...and so on.
Apparently, Taltos was originally going to be titled Easterner, which fits.
But yes, it's pretty clear that Vlad gets his "Teckla lesson," as it were, from Paresh.
(And to the theme of the perspectives, we get another look at what Paresh describes in another book.)
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday November 24, 2009 11:38am EST
As far as "since" goes, Dzur does something similar, pairing each course at Valabar's with the contents of each chapter (although the relationship is more symbolic than literal, as with Teckla).
Tuesday November 24, 2009 11:38am EST
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday November 24, 2009 03:29pm EST
Now Taltos, I dunno, I dind't like that at the time.
Tuesday November 24, 2009 04:19pm EST
My copy of The Book of Jhereg just now arrived; it includes JHEREG, YENDI, and TECKLA... and is almost 500 pages.
How do you do it? I am midway through Daryl Gregory's first novel, have two other books for which I owe reviews to the publishers, and now you are posting reviews of Steven Brust's oeuvre (whose novels, almost always, I thrust to the top of the heap) at the pace of 3/week! And, damnit, you make each book you review -- or even comment on tangentially -- a compelling purchase, if not read.
I thought I read fast, but you are a speed demon. I cannot order the books fast enough to keep up... And you already are on to the next.
Happy Holidays,
David
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday November 24, 2009 07:12pm EST
I know several people who read much faster than I do.
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday November 24, 2009 09:56pm EST
Of course, all Dragaera novels are more complex than they appear, and I still got to like it for that aspect.
Tuesday November 24, 2009 10:34pm EST
This is possibly my favorite thing about the series. Brust deliberately created a world in which his own closely held beliefs go against the laws of nature. That's an awfully impressive way to keep your story from being buried under a pot of message.
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday November 24, 2009 10:54pm EST
Um, almost, but not quite. Remember that Brust is inordinately fond of the unreliable narrator. It is Verra who says that Socialism can't possibly work on Dragaera -- and it certainly can't while she and the other gods remain in power. It's part of the fundamental laws of *her* universe, but not *the* universe, if you see the distinction.
There was a time before there were gods on Dragaera, and there might yet be a time after. Vlad might even be actively be involved in such a transition, given the weapon he gains in _Issola_.
That said, the publication history of the Paarfi books suggests that the Empire and Cycle continue in much their present form for at least another 240 years. It seems unlikely that Kelly will ever see his revolution succeed.
VIEW ALL BY · Tuesday November 24, 2009 11:35pm EST
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday November 25, 2009 12:46am EST
In some ways, you could compare this book to Mieville's Iron Council, but where I felt Mieville retreated into empty symbolism to mitigate his downer ending, I felt that Brust keeps his downer ending with a tacit and frank acknowledgement that the Dragaera have not resolved any of these feelings, but simply crushed their loudest vessels.
Also having Vlad question not only his origins, but the fact his ostensible profit and entire life is built from the misery of his kinspeople is done in such a believable and interesting manner.
Teckla was the book where I thought, "Hey there _is_ something more to these books."
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday November 25, 2009 01:26am EST
Unlike most of Brust's books, which are quite complex and layered, the politics were simplistic and naive. Also, for a fantasy/scifi series, a socialist movement doesn't really make a lot of sense.
Also, this was the one book that I had figured out the easy answer about 3 pages into it. It was a little disappointing to figure it out that quick
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday November 25, 2009 06:50am EST
Hi John, genuinely curious, why would you say that?
Wednesday November 25, 2009 08:02am EST
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday November 25, 2009 08:43am EST
I'd be very interested if Paarfi (or anyone else in Mr Brust's stable) wrote a story set in a Teckla Republic.
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday November 25, 2009 10:22am EST
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday November 25, 2009 10:28am EST
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday November 25, 2009 06:12pm EST
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday November 25, 2009 08:27pm EST
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday November 25, 2009 08:57pm EST
VIEW ALL BY · Wednesday November 25, 2009 09:46pm EST
Wednesday November 25, 2009 10:41pm EST
Pamela
Monday November 30, 2009 05:15pm EST