Nov 6 2013 2:00pm
Rereading Joe Abercrombie’s First Law Trilogy, The Blade Itself: “The King’s Justice” and “Means of Escape”

Joe Abercrombie The Blade ITself First Law Trilogy After Ferro’s introduction and some sweet discussions on the Magi, this week might be something of a disappointment. We’re back to CSI: Adua with Glokta. First, through Jezal’s POV, Glokta reveals the Mercers’ plot in Open Council, then Glokta executes the King’s warrant against the guild.

There continues to be a sense that a storm is coalescing in Adua. Logen and Bayaz are nearing, Ferro and the Dogman are on their way (although we don’t really know that yet), and Glokta and Jezal are in the middle of the political disaster that is the Union. I’m ready for it to happen!!

But, not this week.

“The King’s Justice”

Short and Sweet: Jezal observes the Open Council as Glokta presents evidence of the Mercer conspiracy to defraud the Union. The Mercers are dissolved as a result, and their trade rights granted to the Inquisition for the foreseeable future.

Long and Sour: Jezal dan Luthar and his subordinate, Lieutenant Janelhorm, are part of the detachment guarding the Open Council session in the Lord’s Round. More crowded that usual, both recognize that something is afoot. When four of the Union’s most powerful noblemen arrive, followed by three members of the Closed Council, their suspicions are confirmed.

Chamberlain Hoff declares there is one matter before the Open Council, “A matter concerning the royal license for trade in the city of Westport.” The topic turns the stomach of the four nobleman. Hoff gives Arch Lector Sult the floor.

Recognizing the Guild of Mercers’ contribution in the victory over the Gurkhish, and the trade license they received in thanks, Sult accuses them of high treason in conspiring to steals the King’s taxes. The nobles demand proof and Sult is more than happy to provide it, vis-à-vis Sand dan Glokta.

A parade of prisoners enters the Lord’s Round—Salem Rews, Carpi, and Hornlach—and quickly sing their confessions as Glokta conducts. While the nobles are outraged, there’s little that can be done to refute their testimony. High Justice Marovia, clearly displeased by the development, admits that the evidence is quite clear. Sentiment for the Mercers quickly dissipates among the gallery, and the King’s Justice is called upon. Before ordering Lieutenant Janelhorm to execute the Council’s writ against the Mercers, the Westport trade license is given to the Inquisition for safe keeping.

After the King’s Justice is dispensed, Jezal takes to the streets where he runs into Lieutenant Brint and Ardee West. The pair seem entirely too comfortable with one another. Jezal breaks it up in petulant fashion, ordering Brint to get back to work.

In discussing the days events, namely the Mercer’s dissolution, Ardee remarks, “You wouldn’t want to get one the wrong side of [Glokta], crippled or not.” Jezal agrees and ponders on the virtues of the woman on his arm. If only she had better blood and more money.

Important Characters Introduced: None.

Minor Characters Introduced: Lord Brock, Lord Isher, Lord Heugen, Lord Barezin

Quotes to Remember:

He saw Sult smirking across at High Justice Marovia. The old man’s face was stony blank, but his fists were clenched tight on the table before him.

I include this quote because it’s the first real indication we have that there’s an ongoing battle among the Union Elite. Sult has demonstrated ample ill will toward the “working class,” but now we can see all is not right in Camelot. Marovia, seemingly highly respected by all, is not pleased with Sult’s maneuvering.

“Until such a time as suitable candidates are found, the routes will be managed by capable, loyal, hands. The hands of his Majesty’s Inquisition.”

Orly? I’m stunned. Not really.

Stuff I Noticed: I’m always fascinated by chapters where its told from the point of view of completely passive observer. In this case, most of the chapter is Jezal watching other characters do things, mostly Glokta. This is the fourth or fifth chapter of this nature, all involving the Closed or Open Councils. Of course, Abercrombie never gives us the point of view of someone actually on these governing bodies so this is really the only tool left to him.

Interestingly, he never shows the evidence presented by Sult and Glokta in the Closed Council regarding the Mercers’ guilt. It means we have no idea what kind of documented evidence the Inquisition possesses confirming the testimony by the tortured merchants. All we know is what Jezal observes. Two things stood out to be as possessing great significance:

  1. Lord Brock has much to lose by the Mercers being dissolved. He also seems genuinely shocked at the cavalier nature members of the Closed Council seem to be treating torture.
  2. High Justice Marovia is neutered to opposing the Inquisition, but he does not like the taste his impotence leaves in his mouth. What’s unclear is whether that’s out of some sense of right and wrong, or whether he’s just mad that Sult got one up on him in the proverbial Game of Thrones, to steal a term from GRRM.

With the revelation that the Mercers revenue stream will be delivered to the Inquisition I’m left wondering whether that was the whole point. Did all of this machination take place solely to give the Inquisition more revenue? And to what end? Merely for Sult’s enrichment? Or does he have some larger goal in mind?


“Means of Escape”

The Long and Short of It: Lieutenant Jalenhorm and Inquisitor Glokta serve the Mercers Guild with notice of their treasons as ruled by the Council. Glokta finds Magister Kault with a noose around his neck and a determination to die rather than be questioned. Before he takes a leap into the abyss, Kault admits to his treasons against the King, but implicates other culprits—the banks, the University, the Closed Council, and Glokta’s own House of Questions. The ravings of a man with nothing to lose or the true utterances of the condemned? Glokta wonders.

Important Characters Introduced: Valint and Balk (not a character in the classic sense, but… important)

Minor Character Introduced: Glokta’s Gums.

Quotes to Remember:

“We never had any choices! We had to pay the bankers! They loaned us the money, and we had to pay! We’ve been paying them for years! Valint and Balk, the bloodsuckers! We gave them everything, but they always wanted more!”

Joe Abercrombie. Probably not a licensed stock broker I’m guessing.

Cheap clothes and expensive windows. If the cloth had been stronger we would have got him. If the window had more lead, we would have got him. Lives hinge on such chances.

One of Abercrombie’s classic little lines that observe the vagaries of life and the tiny details that make a difference between success and failure.

Between the Lines: Another quick hitting Glokta chapter, “Means of Escape” reveals little new except for introducing a new player into the political landscape—the bank of Valint and Balk. They are the hand behind everything in the Union, a fact that will become clear very soon to those who would replace the Mercers in the mechanism. As we observed in the previous chapter, that’s going to be Sult and Glokta.

In these revelations some of Abercrombie’s other themes are starting to come to light. Although the meat of the series is about subverting epic fantasy, there’s also some very real comments on more traditional literary themes. You know, the human condition, etc. On top of that Abercrombie offers some insights into the nature of wealth and our obsession with it. Kault’s illusion of wealth, gilded crown molding and ornate clothing, is dispelled when he dies. Glokta realizes it was all a show and that the Mercers were perhaps no better off than anyone else. It’s easy to draw some conclusions about what the author might be saying about our own hierarchies of wealth and privilege.


Next week: Major West gets some good bad news (to war!) and Logen (finally) arrives in Adua. Bayaz attempts to put lipstick on a pig.

Justin Landon runs Staffer’s Book Review where his posts are less on-color. Find him on Twitter for meanderings on science fiction and fantasy, and to argue with him about whatever you just read.

Cory S.
1. Hungry_For_Hands
Not much to add here to the discussion. However, I wanted to stop in and say that I am really enjoying the re-read and follow it every week. (even though I rarely contribute).
Dustin Freshly
2. Fresh0130
Still don't have my copy in hand so I'm going off of memory again...

Another couple of chapters on indifference, although of a different sort altogether.

Here we finally see the motivation that Sult has had from the begining, funneling wealth through the Inquisition and by proxy through his hands.

The indifference comes in that Sult gives not a damn about how he goes about aquiring said wealth.

We've seen Sult condemn men who, while certainly not the most innocent folks you're likely going to meet in Fantasy, are only in his path to increased wealth to lives that are arguably worse than death, we won't see said lives until the next novel, but he does so with a casual wave of his hand just to enrich his own.

Obviously you can take into account the growing pile of bodies at his feet as well and it has to make the reader shake their heads in disgust that all we've seen Glokta do in the name of the "King's Justice" was merely to this end.

Now, we're a very long way from seeing why Sult is doing all of this, but even in the early going most everyone can agree that despicable is a pretty light term for what Sult has done.

So, how guilty is Glokta by indifferent association? He's been Sult's direct hand in all of this, he's the guy creating and disappearing the casualities in Sult's scheme. He knows on some level exactly why Sult is doing what he's doing, he admits as much, but did it any way. Granted Glokta's motivations are completely different, but he's engine moving the proverbial train here in Adua.

Again, I'll jump back in with more when I get a chance or I get the book in front of me, just getting the ball rolling...
3. Malbon
See, this is why Glokta's great. This is quite obviously a world where morals are only for show (and we'll be proved this again in a couple of chapters when Major West, the only genuinely moral man we've yet met, stats to do some pretty terrible things himself). Glokta being Glokta is self aware enough to know exactly how terrible he is, but cynical enough not to lose a lot of sleep over it. That's why all the really great social commentary in this series happens during his chapters. If we had to read this kind of moralizing from a saintly character we'd immediately balk at it, finding it heavy-handed and a little to preachy. But when the nastiest character in a book full of nasty men takes the time to notice that things are wrong, we sit up and take notice as well.

Its also important to realize that Glokta, having lost forever the heroism he felt was his due has consciouslydecided to become the villain everybody sees himself to be. This fact will come back to him later, again and again when he finds himself doing good and is even more surprised than we are.

"Means Of Escape" is also the chapter where Glokta first starts to go against Sult, our at least behind his back, as he starts to learn things the Arch Lector doesn't want his trained dog to know.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment