Jul 24 2013 10:00am

A New Post-Apocalyptic Fantasy: Brandon Sanderson’s “Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell”

Dangerous Women Brandon Sanderson is no stranger to post-apocalyptic fantasy. Global cataclysms form the backdrop for his Mistborn novels, The Stormlight Archive, and Elantris. Even The Wheel of Time series, which he helped complete, takes place in a world defined by having already been broken. So to say that “Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell,” Sanderson’s new short story in the upcoming Dangerous Women anthology, is a post-apocalyptic fantasy may not surprise you. That being said, Sanderson is doing something new with what we might call his favorite sub-genre. “Shadows for Silence” displays a kind of desperation and hopelessness; it gave me a sense of a world that had been truly abandoned, without the customary promise of salvation that I’ve come to expect from Sanderson. And the reason for that, I think, is the way this world is at risk of being depleted.

The world in which “Shadows for Silence in the Forest of Hell” is set has been invaded by something the inhabitants call “the Evil,” a force that manifests in the Shades. These ghostly presences haunt the forest that seems to cover much of the world, and they enforce a series of Simple Rules. “Don’t kindle flame, don’t shed the blood of another, don’t run at night.” If you do any of these things, the Shades will come, and they will ruin you. The touch of a shade withers flesh, and if they catch you they will turn you into dust, allowing your spirit to rise as another Shade. Ghosts with a strong zombie theme.

So what can humans do? How do people live in this world? Well, there’s one thing that can hold Shades back: silver. Shades and silver are mutually destructive, so when a shade comes in contact with silver it is wounded, while the silver rots away into useless dust. Of course, silver is expensive, difficult to come by, and ultimately finite. Silence Malone, our grim protagonist, has more trouble procuring enough silver to maintain her safe inn in the middle of the forest every year.

Silver is an interesting material for Sanderson to make essential here. Mistborn fans are well acquainted with magically essential metals; allomancers ingest metals and burn them to perform a variety of magics. But not all metals are important in Mistborn. Silver, in particular, has no allomantic properties whatsoever. An allomancer who tried to burn it would sicken and potentially die. Sanderson originally intended silver to be an allomantic metal, and planned for it to dramatically improve a “Silvereyes’” senses. However, during research he discovered that pewter wasn’t actually an alloy of silver, despite the claims made to him by hobby store salesmen in his youth, so he replaced silver with tin.

As nice as it is to see silver get its moment in the shade, “Shadows for Silence” still made me feel deeply anxious about the sustainability of humanity on this world. Silver isn’t just some currency, it’s an essential lifeline, and it gets used up while keeping people alive. Sanderson has commoditized safety, monetized the ability to sleep well at night without fear of turning into a horrific ghost, and in doing so created a sense of long-term hopelessness that’s rather chilling.

In this way “Shadows for Silence in the Forests of Hell” reminded me most of the beginning of the third Mistborn novel, The Hero of Ages. The first two hundred pages of that book are grim. Things are bad, humanity is being slowly choked to death by forces beyond their power to fight against, and it’s hard to see how things are ever going to get better. But there’s a crucial difference: the Mistborn trilogy had heroes, brave, powerful people who I believed were going to succeed in the end. People who wanted to make a difference and were empowered to do so. I don’t see any such heroes here. Silence has no one to rely on but herself and her family. She struggles constantly to scrape out an existence, and every victory comes with significant sacrifice. She doesn’t have global ambitions, nor would she be able to bring them about if she did. It makes sense to me now why Sanderson said this story was set in “an unimportant shardworld.” This isn’t a place with heroes waiting to save the day. It isn’t gearing up for a titanic battle against evil that will set the world right. The titanic events are in this world’s past, and there’s nowhere for anyone to go but down.

Brandon Sanderson takes that gloomy mood and makes of it a fantastic spin on his established oeuvre. He’s created a melancholic, desperate adventure that is recognizably his own but still very different, tonally, from what has come before. Sanderson excels at populating his world with powerful optimists. Kelsier and Elend are planners, doers, people who will strive with everything they have to save what they care about, and who have the greatness of heart to care about everything and everyone. Although Kaladin has his dark moments, he has the capacity to throw everything he has into protecting his soldiers, and the fire to bounce back from a history that should have broken him. When faced with impossible odds, most of Sanderson’s protagonists get stronger, work harder, and achieve more. As powerful a message as those characters send, it’s great to see Sanderson breaking out of his mold, showing that he can write characters who only succeed at a nearly insufferable price. Eschewing his standard models will only make his writing richer.

Carl Engle-Laird is the editorial assistant for He is one of the Way of Kings rereaders and’s resident Stormlight Archive correspondent. He would prefer it if the zombie ghosts would leave this place. You can follow him on Twitter.

Robert Dickinson
1. ChocolateRob
Nitpicking and off topic I know but...
Silver is extremely useful for allomancers, just not by itself. Any Mistborn worth his salt is going to want to use it to make Gold into Electrum. Although a bit of a shame that very few of them knew this in the main trilogy.
It is interesting how useless metals mixed with Allomantic ones can make another very useful metal but especially with Silver/Electrum because Gold is seen as the most useless Allomantic metal yet when used as Electrum it is, in practical terms, possibly the the most useful of the basic sixteen. Not only that but another Gold alloy - Malatium - plays an extremely important, one time only role near the end of The Final Empire.
OK I think I got through that without actually giving any real spoilers, anyone who has read the Mistborn trilogy should understand me and anyone who hasn't should be appropriately baffled.

@ Carl. On the correct topic now I was at a book signing in Manchester (November 2011) where Brandon read the start of this story, If I remember correctly he said that he had only just written it on the plane over to England and was on a very early draft.
I'm just wondering if you have heard a reading of the original draft in order to compare it to the finished version.
The reading did not really reveal anything about the world the story was set in, it could quite easily be set in an isolated and superstitious area of any mundane world.
I'm mostly curious to know if the lack of world building was because it was such an early draft that the world you describe in your review simply hadn't been built yet. (I have an audio recording of the reading if you're interested in me posting it.)
Robert Dickinson
2. ChocolateRob
OK, ignore the second half of my above post, I jumped straight into this article and commented before I noticed the article below it which is the written form of the reading I was talking about. I'll just leave myself looking a little foolish rather than edit my comment to remove the second half.
I do have the advantage however of being able to listen to my recording of the reading while comparing it to the finished written version. So far it is word for word except for one name change. Ho hum.
Alice Arneson
3. Wetlandernw
My great curiosity at the moment is just this: "That fellow in the corner, though… dressed all in brown, still wearing his hat despite being indoors. That fellow looked truly dangerous." Is this, by any chance, Hoid? Not sure why he'd be in the Forests, but following the rule that he shows up in all the Cosmere stories... he's the best candidate.
4. askthepaperclip
Hmm, I just noticed all the uses of "friend." Is "Daggon" another cameo by a certain world-hopping Dula?! The names even sound similar, in an anagram/palindrome/rhyming kind of way... (I know, it isn't really any of those, but still...)
Jan Grilanc
6. DrRoxo
Brandon Sanderson is no stranger to post-apocalyptic fantasy. Global cataclysms form the backdrop for his Mistborn novels, The Stormlight Archive, and Elantris.
Uh, guys? Isn't The Stormlight Archive being post-apocalyptic kinda spoilerish? We don't really find that out until quite late in the first book...
7. OHearn
The Prelude to Stormlight says there have been apocalyptic wars called Desolations, and that something horrible was done to end them that might come back to haunt the world later. But it doesn't give details as to how or why. Then the next chapter fast-forwards 4500 years.

That's the first 4 pages of the book. I mostly disagree that Stormlight is post-apocalyptic though. It's true that there were Desolations, but they're so far in the past. For the past 4500 years, so far as we know, technology and culture have only increased.
8. UW Hwt
I love Brandon Sanderson’s work - I will hesitate to buy this book as it has G.R.R. Martin’s involvement. Martin seems to have all of the excuses in the world not to complete his own series. It's too bad that he doesn't have Brandon Sanderson’s discipline and work ethic...
Alice Arneson
9. Wetlandernw
@8 - You have three options. 1) Miss a great story. 2) Buy the anthology despite GRRM. 3) Wait and hope that Brandon's story gets published elsewhere someday. :)

Unless there's some kind of agreement that the stories in the anthology will never be published elsewhere, I'd think that last would happen eventually. It's too good not to, if it can be done.
Andrew Hamilton
10. SirJerric
@8 & 9 - I plan to use option 2b) Ask my local library to buy the anthology. A sale still occurs, I still read as many of the stories within as I wish, other library patrons can enjoy it too, and if I like the contents will enough, I'll buy my own copy.
11. Ellynne
I'm going to argue that the story isn't hopeless--far from it, in fact. Silence's daughter asks her mother what it would take for her to see a miracle instead of coincidence. Silence is a cynic, fighting because she can't give up. By her standard, there are no miracles in this story. By her daughter's standard, the story is full of them. There are also hints how the Evil that threatens their world might be destroyed someday.
Anthony Pero
12. anthonypero
@9, @10--I bought the audiobook with my Audible subscription. Totally worth it. There are a lot of great stories in there, including a Dresden Files story from Molly's perspective, which was a fun listen.
Alice Arneson
13. Wetlandernw
Just in case anyone cares, the man in brown is NOT Hoid.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment