Fri
Mar 29 2013 10:30am

Under Heaven, Everything is Different: River of Stars by Guy Gavriel Kay

River of Stars Guy Gavriel Kay Book Review

Legends are not born, but made. Not fated, but carefully—or carelessly—shaped.

A lesson for the ages, there, but not one that every scholar takes to heart.

“Is it possible... can a man be born into the world to be something, for something?”
“Yes,” said the old man. “But even if he is, it doesn’t always happen. Too much can intervene. The world does what it does, under heaven. Our dreams, our certainties, crash into each other.”
“Like swords?” Daiyan said.
The old man shrugged. “Like swords, like ambitions at court.”
A silence.

Despite this oft-voiced thought, Ren Daiyan has felt possessed by something resembling destiny from an early age. As a boy of fifteen scant summers at the outset of Guy Gavriel Kay’s sublime new novel River of Stars, he is asked to help protect the sub-prefect on a gift-giving mission through treacherous territory. Thrilled by the prospect of “keeping order for the emperor” in some small way, he accepts the request.

Bandits fall upon the caravan in short order. Surprising everyone except himself, Daiyan single-handedly slaughters them all.

“What followed on that lonely path between forest and cliffs felt destined, necessary, not truly a matter of choosing. It was more as if the choice had been made for him, he was only the agency of its working.” Soon, he is revered as a local hero—and the legend of his life which River of Stars examines has begun.

It is a dark time for the empire under heaven, however, regardless of Daiyan’s grand designs:

The Silk Roads through the deserts were lost, cut off by barbarians.
No western treasures flowed to Kitai now, to the trading cities or the court in Hanjin. No legendary green-eyed, yellow-haired dancing girls bringing seductive music. No jade and ivory or exotic fruits, no wealth of silver coins brought by merchants to buy longed-for Kitan silk and carry it back west on camels through the sands.
This Twelfth Dynasty of Kitai under their radiant and glorious emperor did not rule and define the known world. Not any more.

Indeed, this is an empire diminished in every which way, which is to say from within its more modest borders as well as outwith. Unrest is on the rise: peasant rebellions and political protests are now par for the course. The great walls which once encompassed Kitai have crumbled. In turn, the glittering court has been humbled. And all the while, barbarians beat at the gates.

Though Daiyan is “serenely convinced” that he will one day regain the fabled Fourteen—namely the outermost prefectures lost to the empire long ago—if Kitai is to survive, never mind thrive, its future will be fashioned by other hands than his.

Other hands... such as Lin Shan’s. The only daughter of the court gentleman Lin Kuo, she has been educated, against all the guidance of the time, much as a male child might be:

She wasn’t, of course, going to write any examinations, or wear robes with the belt of any rank at all, but her father had given her the learning to do so. And he had made her perfect her writing skills and the brush strokes of her calligraphy.
The songs, the ci, she had discovered on her own.

Shan comes to consider her unique upbringing a boon, however, I fear few others do. As she puts it, “men tend to be made uneasy, or sometimes amused, by [her intelligence],” while women outright dislike her. Yet she is a self-sufficient girl at the outset, and her determination develops with each subsequent summer. She comes of age quickly, and is promptly married off. But she does not simply submit to her husband. Instead, they become friends... equals, even—at least until the emperor himself takes an interest in Shan and her songs.

These events certainly factor in to who she is, but their impact is underpinned by her unwavering sense of self. To wit, though she does not know what to make of the emperor’s fascination in the first, she is certain not to become some pretty pet or accessory. In her way, if I may, Shan proves as pivotal to Kitai as Daiyan dreams of being—albeit in a roundabout manner returning readers are likely to find familiar.

No real poet would claim originality for an image of streams becoming rivers over distance and time: how even those that can destroy farmlands with their flooding, or thunder through gorges and over falls, begin as rivulets in the rocks of mountains, or underground waters that find the surface and being to flow across the land to find the sea.
Nor could the idea that rivers come together to make a single force be asserted as distinctive. The test is always in the words—and the brush strokes shaping them. There are only so many ideas, so many patterns in the world.

That Guy Gavriel Kay has the confidence to acknowledge this is testament to his inimitable vision and ability, I think. After all, River of Stars does describe a rather archetypal pattern, especially as regards the author’s own body of work. Themes and thoughts he has explored before reappear with some frequency. His protagonists occasionally behave in unsurprising ways, recalling heroes and stories of yore.

River of Stars Guy Gavriel Kay Book Review

But don’t dare be dismayed, because these things are only as similar, in this iteration, as they are different. The quarter turn the author often talks about also returns, and in River of Stars it applies to narrative and character as well as questions of setting. Here, you see, some rivulets become rivers, but others simply trickle, or dry up entirely. Great tales in the making are regularly interrupted, whilst a number of dreams come to nothing. As Kay contends:

Small events can be important in the unfolding, like a pleated sail, of the world. The survival of an emissary, say, or his drowning on a ship in a sudden summer thunderstorm.
But sometimes such moments do not signify in the sweep and flow of events, though obviously they will matter greatly to those who might have thought their lives were ending in rain and wins, and for those who love them dearly and would have grieved for their loss.

This, too, is an idea the award-winning author has put in the past—in The Last Light of the Sun, for one—but here he voices it so often, and so powerfully, that it is more than an incidental omen. It is a warning that the reader cannot but take to heart; a statement instead of a suggestion. Therefore a sense of terrible dread demarcates the redoubtable delights we have come to expect from Kay’s fantastic fiction, gathering in force and scope as it goes.

In short, certain elements must be expected in order for the unexpected to be effective, and in River of Stars, it is.

Or is it?

I’m sorry. Sometimes I can’t help myself. River of Stars really does pack a punch, in large part because of the way Kay plays with our expectations, engineering difference and originality out of our expectations of his characters and narratives—and the same can be asserted of the text’s refreshed setting.

If the truth be told, few things in life get me quite as excited as the prospect of a new novel from this master craftsman. Nevertheless, I know I was not alone in wishing—when we first heard that River of Stars would return to the empire investigated in Under Heaven—that the author had channelled his inimitable imagination into a wonderful new world rather than returning to Kitai.

To all those who worried with me: rest easy. Centuries have passed since the Tagurans gifted Shen Tai with two hundred and fifty gorgeous horses, cursing him with kindness in the process, and time has absolutely ravaged Kitai. What once shimmered like a jewel in moonlight has not utterly dulled, but must of its lustre is, alas, lost—its glory is gone, sacrificed alongside a large expanse of land. Here’s how Daiyan’s embittered instructor phrases this change:

The spring tea harvest had been dismal, desperate, and the fields for rice and vegetables were far too dry. This autumn’s crops had been frighteningly sparse. There hadn’t been any tax relief, either. The emperor needed money, there was a war. Teacher Tuan had things to say about that, too, sometimes reckless things.
[...]
He’d told them that Xinan, the capital of glorious dynasties, had held two million people once, and that only a hundred thousand or so lived there now, scattered among rubble. He’d said that Tagur, to the west of them here, across the passes, had been a rival empire long ago, fierce and dangerous, with magnificent horses, and that it was now only a cluster of scrabbling provinces and fortified religious retreats.

Ultimately, Twelfth Dynasty Kitai is so very different from the empire Under Heaven’s readers will remember that it proves almost as satisfying as an entirely new milieu—and what little we do lose in lieu of another culture in place of Kay’s impeccable portrayal of ancient China, we gain elsewhere, given how resonant River of Stars is with affectionate connections to its predecessor.

To be completely clear: you most certainly don’t have to have read Under Heaven to appreciate Kay’s latest—in fact, I can’t imagine anyone coming away from this dazzling display feeling less than elated—but poignant nods to the characters, concerns and consequences of his masterful last fantasy make the return trip to Kitai that much more fulfilling.

It may be that you think you know what River of Stars is. You don’t, though. As samey as I can see it seeming in some ways, rest assured that its every dimension is distinct in some sense. I suppose it hones closer to the author’s other novels than Under Heaven—an outright exception to the pattern he has established over the years, and a revelation in its quiet way—but River of Stars is no less enthralling for its passing familiarity... which Kay plays into marvellously in any event.

I got just what I wanted out of River of Stars, and I wanted an awful lot. I wanted fundamentally memorable and delicately developed characters, a massively ambitious narrative, an exquisitely rendered setting, and prose so finely honed that it has all the impact of fine art. These are just a few of the things I’ve come to expect from Guy Gavriel Kay over the years, and he does not disappoint here.

Far from it. Kay on a bad day remains many times more absorbing than the vast majority of other genre authors, and I dare say River of Stars chronicles him on a great day. This is stunning stuff from one of fantasy fiction’s finest. From one of fiction’s finest, frankly.


Niall Alexander is an erstwhile English teacher who reads and writes about all things weird and wonderful for The Speculative Scotsman, Strange Horizons, and Tor.com, where he contributes a weekly column concerned with news and new releases in the UK called the British Genre Fiction Focus, and co-curates the Short Fiction Spotlight. On rare occasion he’s been seen to tweet about books, too!

16 comments
S Cooper
1. SPC
Would you say one should have read Under Heaven to appreciate this book, or does it stand entirely on its own? I love some of Kay's other books, but just couldn't get into Under Heaven for some reason.
Bill Capossere
2. Billcap
this is already on my short list as one of the best books of the year so far and it's hard to imagine it falling much down that list. Simply a great read.
Niall Alexander
3. niallalot
@SPC: I'd say River of Stars stands on its own surprisingly well, however having read Under Heaven beforehand adds incredible resonance to what will seem like passing remarks to anyone who hasn't.

Either way, River of Stars is something else, and you should read it immediately. Rest assured, too, that it's more in the mode of the author's earlier efforts than Under Heaven—which, though magnificent in its way, was by all rights very quiet Kay. Which is to say: I can imagine why you had difficulty getting into it. Truth be told, I did too, but by the end... oh my. What a beautiful book!
Niall Alexander
4. niallalot
@Billcap: Absolutely. I'd be shocked if it didn't make my year-end Best Of bit come Christmas. Alongside The Crane Wife, Life After Life, The Best of All Possible Worlds... maybe even The Machine. We're not even three months in, but 2013's been a hell of year already, hasn't it? :)
Paul Weimer
5. PrinceJvstin
Its been a strong year already. Damn. This is a good problem to have. Also having to pick up the newest Kay is another good problem to have.
Niall Alexander
6. niallalot
@PrinceJvstin: And then NOS4A2, The Shining Girls, Doctor Sleep... the list goes on. This is going to be an awfully hard year to call, I warrant. One more fantastic problem to have!
Karthak
7. Karthak
Under Heaven and River of Stars are both good books, but there is one thing both books have that make me so damn ANGRY that I can't bring myself to reread them, and that is good characters getting villified by history, and incompetent fools getting lionized! Especially in River of Stars. Gods, how Zhizeng made me fantasize about regicide. With a blowtorch.
Karthak
8. Ray Jr
Would like to read, since everyone seems to have very intense feelings about the books.
Karthak
9. yaee
Under Heaven is one of the better books to have come along in recent years - going by this as well as GGK's other books, I can only imagine that River of Stars will be of the same calibre or higher - I am anxious to read it.
Karthak
10. thesnuggler
Hope to read it soon. Tigana was beautifully written.
Karthak
11. Dao and Zen
Really enjoyed "Under Heaven" looking forward to "River"
Karthak
12. Austin Hopper
This sounds great. Makes me want to finally dig into Under Heaven which has been sitting on my shelf for a year now.
Karthak
13. Mary Dailey
I don't know how I have missed this! Looks like I need to read both books!
Karthak
14. Kris Holtan
This may just entice me back to reading Fantasy Novels after years of Historical Fiction leavened with Crime Noir.
Karthak
15. lmohawk
River of Stars has been on my wish list since it came out, waiting for the paperback (more affordable). I hope to get a copy--for a matched set on my bookshelf with Under Heaven.
Karthak
16. Cecrow
Read 'Under Heaven' but didn't get to this one yet; could be good.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment