Mon
Jan 21 2013 12:00pm
A Read of the Dark Tower: Constant Reader Tackles Wolves of the Calla, Part 2, “Telling Tales”: Chapter 2, “Dry Twist”

A Read of the Dark Tower: Constant Reader Tackles Wolves of the Calla, Part 2, “Telling Tales”: Chapter 2, “Dry Twist”

“First comes smiles, then lies. Last is gunfire.”

—Roland Deschain, of Gilead

Welcome to A Read of the Dark Tower series. Join me each week as I, Constant Reader, tackle the magnum opus of Stephen King’s career for the first time. If you want to discuss in general terms or talk about these first sections, join me by commenting here.

We last left our ka-tet bedding down at Callahan’s rectory at Calla Bryn Sturgis, all but for Jake, who’d gone home with his new friend Benny Slightman.

 

Wolves of the Calla—“Telling Tales,” Chapter 2, “Dry Twist,” Section 1

Roland wakes up after another dream of Jericho Hill. There’s something about Arthur Eld’s horn, which was lost in the battle. But it is pain that wakes him, not the dream itself, so he lies next to the sleeping Callahan (a visual I don’t want to ponder too long) and thinks.

He hurts from hip to ankle, partly his punishment for the previous night’s dancing. But he knows it isn’t just “rheumatiz,” as he’s been telling himself the past few weeks as his hip gave him pain. He’d noticed his ankles and knees thickening, and knew it was arthritis—“the bad kind, the dry kind.” He worries about losing the use of his hands. He figures he has less than a year before he’s crippled with it.

He knows he’ll still pursue his goal: “Not that he would cry off the Tower if Old Bone-Twist Man took his ability to shoot, saddle a horse, cut a strip of rawhide, even to chop wood for a campfire…But he didn’t relish the picture of riding along behind the others, dependent upon them, perhaps tied to his saddle with the reins because he could no longer hold the pommel.”

He briefly thinks he’ll kill himself before letting that happen, but knows he is kidding himself, as Eddie would say.

He knows he needs to tell Eddie about Susannah ASAP. She’ll find it harder to slip away during the nights now without Eddie knowing.

As the sun rises, Roland is “dismayed to see that brightness no longer bloomed dead east; it was a little off to the south, now. Sunrise was also in drift.”

What Constant Reader Learns: I guess Jericho Hill is weighing so heavily on Roland because he knows whatever they’re going to face with the wolves is going to be bad.

Rheumatoid arthritis runs rampant in my family; nasty stuff, Roland. I shall now call it “dry twist” and be grateful it has thus far passed me by. At least I assume that’s what he refers to.

Reading about Roland’s worries over his health made me wonder where Stephen King was in his accident recovery when he wrote this book. It came out late in 2003; his accident was in 1999. Roland’s aching hip has been mentioned several times in this book but was it mentioned in earlier books? I don’t recall it, and don’t want to dig around reading too much about this fifth book lest I encounter spoilers. Can’t help but project some autobiographical pain and fear of helplessness here, though.

Drifting sunrise can’t be good.

 

Wolves of the Calla—“Telling Tales,” Chapter 2, “Dry Twist,” Section 2

Callahan has a 40ish housekeeper named Rosalita Munoz whom Ro finds attractive. All he has to do is walk across the room and she realizes something’s wrong with him. Roland claims it’s rheumatism. She has a “cat-oil” that will ease his pain.

First, he wants a map of the Calla, and Callahan says he can’t draw worth crap but he knows who can.

What Constant Reader Learns: Callahan says he knows “two that could help” with the map. Twins, perhaps?

 

Wolves of the Calla—“Telling Tales,” Chapter 2, “Dry Twist,” Section 3

Rosalita leads Roland into the pantry and tells him to drop trou. She can tell right away it’s “the kind of arthritis that spreads fast.” Roland says his people call it the “dry twist,” but tells her not to tell Callahan or the others. He will keep the secret as long as he can.

Then, of course, because Roland hasn’t had any since Tull, he and Rosalita share a little bawdy conversation—but in the end what she asks him is to save the “babbies,” no matter what the “big bugs” like Eisenhart and Telford say.

What Constant Reader Learns: The secret ingredient in Rosalita’s tonic is “rock cat” bile—probably puma or cougar. Which begs the question of how said bile is collected.

 

Wolves of the Calla—“Telling Tales,” Chapter 2, “Dry Twist,” Section 4

By the time Roland emerges from the pantry, he can hear Eddie and Susannah stirring in their room. Before they come out, he asks Callahan to send Eddie out alone to join him in picking pokeberries.

What Constant Reader Learns: Uh oh. Sounds like “the conversation” is about to happen.

 

Wolves of the Calla—“Telling Tales,” Chapter 2, “Dry Twist,” Section 5

Eddie joins Roland in picking berries. Roland’s pain has faded, and he cuts the idle chat short. “Listen closely and keep a rein on your emotions,” Roland tells him. “For your father’s sake.”

Eddie listens quietly, and Roland is struck by how much he has grown up. Even when he realizes how long Roland has known without telling him, Eddie stays calm. Roland is his dinh, he says, and he accepts that.

Eddie admits he’s surprised, but that he’s seen some signs. She’s had pain she blames on gas. Her breasts are bigger. But she’s still having her periods—proof, Roland points out, that whatever she’s carrying, it isn’t Eddie’s baby. “Would it even look like a human baby?” Eddie asks, kind of pale-looking. “Almost surely not,” Roland answers, but doesn’t speculate on what it might look like.

What Constant Reader Learns: I like that Roland spares Eddie the gory details of exactly what Susannah is munching on during her evening feasts.

Poor dead Andy Gibb. The world has moved on since Eddie promised not to “faint like a girl at an Andy Gibb concert.” Shadow dancing.

Eddie gives a great summary of their situation: “Over here, the Wolves come in twenty-four days…Over there in New York, who knows what day it is? The sixth of June? The tenth? Closer to July fifteenth than it was yesterday, that’s for sure….If what she’s got inside her isn’t human, we can’t be sure her pregnancy will go nine months. Hell, she might pop it tomorrow.” Indeed.

 

Wolves of the Calla—“Telling Tales,” Chapter 2, “Dry Twist,” Section 6

On the way back to the rectory, Eddie asks Roland why he doesn’t tell Susannah the truth. Roland says he’s afraid Mia, who’s protecting her child, could take over Susannah the way Detta Walker sometimes did Odetta. Eddie spells it out: “You don’t want to tell Suze she might be growing a monster in her belly because it might impair her efficiency.”

Basically, Roland agrees. He awaits an angry outburst from Eddie, but again Eddie is sad but steady. “It’s the rose I care about,” he says. “That’s the only thing worth risking her for. But even so, you’ve got to promise me that if things go wrong, we’ll try to save her.”

Roland agrees, but he can’t shake the mental image of Jake dangling off the side of the mountain trestle just before he lets the boy fall.

What Constant Reader Learns: Is this foreshadowing on Roland’s part, or just his ongoing guilt over letting Jake die in the mountains?

 

Wolves of the Calla—“Telling Tales,” Chapter 2, “Dry Twist,” Section 7

Eddie and Roland walk back into the rectory as Callahan is saying goodbye to a set of twins, a boy and girl who are beautiful. The Tavery twins, Frank and Francine, will be drawing Roland’s map of the Calla.

Roland ushers the twins outside and down the walk of the rectory, talking to them, struck not just by their beauty but the intelligence in their eyes—he realizes Callahan has called them not only for a map but as a reminder that in less than a month, one of them would be roont if nothing was done. “Fear me not,” Roland tells them. “But hear me well.”

What Constant Reader Learns:  Hm....wonder what role Roland has found for the children?

 

Wolves of the Calla—“Telling Tales,” Chapter 2, “Dry Twist,” Section 8

Eddie watches Roland conversing with the twins and thinks he looks like a benevolent grandpere.

Susannah comes in to flirt with Eddie, and he finds himself looking for signs of Mia in her. He wonders how much of their relationship will change. She can tell something is bothering him and asks, but he said nothing—except that “were’re probably all going to die here.”

What Constant Reader Learns:  Eddie’s really bothered that he’s having to lie to Susannah so blatantly. I have to admit, I’m really, really curious as to how this whole invisible-demon-baby-spawn thing is going to play out.

 

Wolves of the Calla—“Telling Tales,” Chapter 2, “Dry Twist,” Section 9

After more coffee and pokeberries, the three ka-tet members and Callahan go into the backyard. Roland also wants to see the church.

“I want you to take it,” Callahan says. He doesn’t say what “it” is, but everyone knows he means Black Thirteen. The church was never consecrated, but he used to be able to feel God inside it. No more.

Before Roland can answer, Susannah asks if he’s okay—she’s noticed him rubbing his hip. The cat-oil is already wearing off. He lies and says it’s the rheumatiz, but inside realizes they can’t keep lying and keeping secrets from each other for too long.

Callahan rubs the crucifix-shaped scar on his forehead and starts his story.

What Constant Reader Learns:  Oh boy. Can’t wait for this next chapter!


That’s it for this week! Next week—same time, same place—we’ll tackle the next chapter of Wolves of the Calla.

20 comments
StrongDreams
1. StrongDreams
Being full of book-learning but little practical experience myself, I confess to having been confused by the differences in arthritis types as described here. "Rheumatoid arthritis" and "osteoarthritis" are indeed two different conditions, but they seem to be equally bad, and at least from WebMD's description, I would think a gunslinger would rather have OA than RA. Maybe in Roland's world "rheumatiz" is their name for osteo and "dry twist" is their name for RA? Or maybe there is something about the two diseases that I am failing to grasp.

Anyway, on the point of autobiography seeping in, more than you know...but you won't find the answer in this book no matter how much you read ahead.
StrongDreams
2. Lsana
I don't think it's a spoiler to say that King's accident was very much on his mind as he was writing this book; he discusses it in one of the Forwards. Primarily it was the fact that the accident reminded him that he was mortal, and therefore that if he wanted the Dark Tower saga to actually finish, he needed to finish it, but it's pretty clear that it was on his mind in other ways as well, such as the references to nagging pain that you noticed.

The world has moved on indeed! I never even heard of Andy Gibbs until I googled him just now.

I'd never noticed this before, but Roland's comments on the drifting sunrise seems a little odd as a "sign the world has moved on." After all, for those of us in the Northern Hemisphere, sunrise is always a little off to the south, and it gets further so as we get closer to winter.
Suzanne Johnson
3. SuzanneJohnson
@StrongDreams...I was confused about the arthritis(es) as well. OA (which I have, sadly) is painful but usually relatively benign. RA is absolutely debilitating. I interpreted "rheumatiz" as being OA in Roland's world--actually, I think it's old rural slang for any kind of arthritis. The joint thickening and anticipated disability Roland is thinking of sounds like RA, though.

@Lsana...Sadly, I'm old enough to remember Andy Gibb all too well. It was a kind of a pathetic time in American musical history :-).
StrongDreams
4. StrongDreams
Is this foreshadowing on Roland’s part, or just his ongoing guilt over letting Jake die in the mountains?

I think what Roland is wrestling with is what kind of man is he now, and has he changed. He dropped Jake to get to the Tower (and let Susan die, and murdered the town of Tull, and so much more). Could he drop Jake or Susannah or Eddie if it was a choice between them or the Tower. If so, he's still a murdering bastard who killed every friend he ever had, as Flagg claimed. If not, he might lose the Tower after everything he's been through--and does that mean that all the previous deaths were for nothing?

And, Constant Reader, you might give some thought to this question: Does Roland, after all he's done, deserve to get to the Tower?
Thomas Thatcher
5. StrongDreams
White text test.

This should be white.
Thomas Thatcher
6. StrongDreams
I think it's a very small spoiler to say that the Crimson King wants to get to the Tower to take over the universe.

Randall Flagg wants to get the Tower to prove to himself that the room at the top is empty, there is no God and no overall Purpose to the universe.

But why does Roland want to get to the Tower? Does he want to save it, or does he merely want to get there as an end to itself, or has he gotten the two confused? What would happen if he got the choice to save the Tower without actually going there in person, and does he deserve to go there in person?
Suzanne Johnson
7. SuzanneJohnson
@StrongDreams...Interesting question. Does Roland deserve to get to the Tower? I think the answer to that lies with something I don't yet know, for sure. Which is: WHY does Roland want so badly to get to the Tower? If it is because he thinks he can repair what is broken, if he is truly the only one left who can set things right, then seems to me he does deserve to get there. Or, after all these many long years, has the Tower become an end in itself? Does he just want to get there because he wants to get there? Then, the people and things he has sacrificed become a kind of a mockery. I'm not much a believer in ka without the element of free will, so, for now at least, I'm hanging my answer to that question on what Roland's motives turn out to be, assuming we ever really know.
Chris Nelly
8. Aeryl
OK, Bookmark this thread to come back to after the last chapter. I mean really, the things discussed that we can't talk about.....


StrongDreams, I pretty much agree with all of your comment.
Suzanne Johnson
9. SuzanneJohnson
LOL. I'll bookmark it. I feel like Ka-tet Tor is having a palaver and I've been stuck on the beach with the lobstrosities, popping astin and trying to read lips. Or something like that.
Thomas Thatcher
10. StrongDreams
Sorry, Suzanne, didn't mean to exclude you from our khef. :)

One of the things that is different about books 5-6-7 is that King wrote them all together, so he knew where he was going and he puts in things that sometimes pay off in later books. (I don't King always knew where the series was going when he wrote the earlier books.) After reading the first few times to find out what happens, I can now take the time to read a long with you and think about why things happen, which is a very rewarding experience.

My own view is that one of the most important arcs in the overall story is Roland's character and his journey back to humanity. He saw the Tower in the pink ball and made a decision that it mattered more than anything else, leading to letting Susan die, killing Allie (in the original version she pleads with him to shoot her, and we know how good a shot he is––I'm still mad at King for changing that), dropping Jake, kidnapping two people, etc. What good is it if he gains the Tower but loses his soul, to steal a phrase. When Roland first pulls Jake through the door in the speaking ring, he knows he would drop Jake again if it came to that. Now he's not sure, and that is progress, of a kind.

And I'll suggest something else. Roland's journey back to humanity seems to parallel King's journey back to sobriety. (Which, if true, makes the ending even more thought-provoking.) I'll venture that the 2002-vintage King who is clean and sober was a lot less comfortable with the Jake and Allie killing bastard he wrote about in 1978-1982, when he was doing coke and drinking 3 gallons of beer a day.
Risha Jorgensen
11. RishaBree
It's an interesting point you raise, StrongDreams. But I have to question whether deserving to make it to the Tower is really beside the point, as long as he has the will and the ability. For some reason, ka has chosen Roland to fight against the rot inside the grass/rose/Tower. It is quite literally impossible for him to have reached this point with these companions without its help. There may have been others who could have taken his place at some point, or who are even now attempting to - we have no way of knowing. But as long as Roland can help, I'd argue that what he does to get there is secondary in importance. Not to him, but to the Tower.
Thomas Thatcher
12. StrongDreams
I'd argue that what he does to get there is secondary in importance. Not to him, but to the Tower.

It certainly is his ka to struggle to save the Tower. But does the end justify all the means?

Spoilers in white:
I think the epilogue proves that the means do matter to the Tower.
End spoilers.

He wants to save the Tower. But he has also sworn to climb the steps of the Tower, calling out all the names of those who have died along the way. What if he could do one without the other?
Chris Nelly
13. Aeryl
StrongDreams:

It absolutely matters.

SPOILERS: Which is why after this story, he now has the horn. What he did mattered, to himself and to the Tower, so he is closer to completing his journey. And, because the CK was still there, he couldn't cry off this time, and go through the door with Susannah. But, next time.....

END SPOILERS

That's why it's so fascinating we've come across this conversation now, because really, that's what these books are all about, and this chapter asks the question and gives you the answer.
Thomas Thatcher
14. StrongDreams
Aeryl, I can't tell if I agree with you or not, because we're being too cryptic for our own good. My view on the epilogue is that:
Cryptic spoiler
Roland had insufficiently regained his humanity. He could have turned around and had a happy retirement, but he pressed on instead.
Spolier over.
But we really need to talk about this later, about 6 months from now I guess.
Chris Nelly
15. Aeryl
I can agree with your spoiler(for the most part).
StrongDreams
16. CallahanOTheRoads
@ 10- In the original version of The Gunslinger, Allie pleads to NOT be shot.
I wonder what would have happened if Roland had taken the Speaking Demon's advice (in Gunslinger) on how to spare Jake's life- "Cry off. Strike your camp and go to the northwest, where there is still a need for men who live by the bullet."
Drake Amendola
17. MynameisDrake
So glad to finally be caught up with these posts! Going to look for my copy of Wolves tomorrow and read along with you for the rest of this series. Hopefully I can take part in some of the interesting conversations you all have been having in the comments!

@10: I've never read the original version of The Gunslinger, but I am sure that in the revised edition Allie begs Roland to kill her after she said "nineteen" to Nort. He shoots her and Sheb almost right away.
Thomas Thatcher
18. StrongDreams
@16, @17,
Yes of course, you are right. I mistyped or something. In the original, Allie is Sheb's human shield, and she begs Roland not to shoot, but he does anyway. In the revised, Allie begs for death because of the "nineteen" garbage King added. One of the main themes of the entire series for me is Roland's slow journey to regain his humanity (with a side-trip to show how he started to lose it), and nothing shows the inhumanity of his starting condition than killing Allie and dropping Jake. King wimped out for some reason and softened Roland, which to me is the greatest mistake of the revised Gunslinger.
Drake Amendola
19. MynameisDrake
Spoilers for the end of the series in white text:

@StrongDreams: You could just chalk it up as being different cycles in Roland's quest. The original edition led Roland to the tower, but he walked back in to the desert again with nothing more than he had the last time. The revised edition is a new continuity, in which Roland only kills Allie due to her wishes. He still lets Jake fall, but he redeems himself in DT when he mourns Jake's death and thinks about giving up the tower. Maybe the Roland we see at the very end of the series, with the Horn of Arthur Eld, won't let Jake fall.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment