Tue
May 29 2012 4:00pm

How Batman Got You Interested in Architecture. Batman: Death By Design

A review of Batman: Death by Design by Chip Kidd and Dave TaylorI was never really interested in architecture until Batman became involved. And I feel kind of weird about that.

New graphic novel Batman: Death by Design is to blame for this. The stand-alone story by designer and art director Chip Kidd and artist Dave Taylor imagines a Batman caper set in an era of gumshoes, art deco, and pulp heroes with decidedly futuristic tech. At first it’s difficult to see where Batman and architecture cross. Gotham City has been depicted in movies and comics as a grand nightmare of form, shadowed alleys and exposed scaffolding tucked under magnificent colossi and towering, stylized edifices. (When it’s not just Chicago, that is.) It’s a perfect backdrop for the Batman, but how do you build a story around it? Does Batman... fight architecture? Can one imagine Christian Bale shaking an architect while intoning, “STOP BUILDING THESE THINGS. IT’S CONFUSING ME”?

By the end of Death by Design, this is no longer a question. If anything, you want the story to keep going.

The story begins during a golden age in Gotham as Bruce Wayne announces the demolition of Wayne Central Station, the city’s aging transit hub. What was once a towering multi-level station that announced the grandeur of Gotham City to incoming travelers is now a degraded, empty vault of little activity. Bruce is championing a new design with Wayne Enterprises—one that is futuristic, green, and progressive.

This design has two key opponents: a shadowy one that tries to collapse a crane onto Bruce during the press conference where he announces the new station, and Cyndia, a tireless, sincere, somewhat Ayn Randian “urban preservationist” who champions the restoration of the original Wayne Central Station to Bruce. These two opponents may or may not be the same person.

Cyndia’s genuine tenacity charms Bruce and through the course of their work they visit a brand new nightclub called The Ceiling, which is little more than a thick glass platform (“a triumph of maxi-minimalism”) suspended above several skyscrapers.

The Ceiling from Batman: Death by Design

Once there, the guests fall prey to an attack by a very dapper Joker, who looks more human than normal and somehow all the more frightening. Batman saves the day, of course, no thanks to Exacto, a new superpowered figure in Gotham who seems like a hero at first but definitely has his own agenda. (One that involves giving stern lectures on architecture and design flaws. He’s an odd duck.)

Through these events, Batman uncovers a tangle of forces both legitimate and underground who all have legacies tied to Wayne Central Station. Some benefit from its destruction, others from its restoration. The more that Batman finds out, the more he realizes how intimately his father’s legacy is tied to this fight, and how much that defines Bruce himself. Should he champion those who would restore and put right what his father attempted? Or should he champion the direction that he himself has imposed on Gotham?

To find such an emotional resonance for Batman through the lens of architecture is a fantastic storytelling achievement in itself, and so those who know of Chip Kidd and his art design background are forced to again wonder if there’s anything he can’t do.

Kidd finds an amazing storytelling partner in artist Dave Taylor, who delivers extremely potent moments all throughout the book, whether it’s through architectural vista (like the above depiction of The Ceiling) or through simple character interaction. There is a page further on in the book featuring the Joker that is exceedingly frightening, and the kicker is that the Joker isn’t doing anything in it.

A review of Batman: Death by Design by Chip Kidd and Dave TaylorI have to admit personal artistic bias towards Taylor, as well, in that I am a total sucker for pencil-only comic illustration. To be sure, there are inks and colors, but the pages look as if they sprang straight from Taylor’s desk, giving the tale a rough vibrancy that matches perfectly with the nebulous pulp-y, roaring 20s-ish period the story is set in.

Kidd & Taylor also sneak in some clever artistic tricks if you’re paying attention. For example, flipping the cover of the book suddenly turns Batman hovering over skyscrapers into Batman amongst the people of Gotham.

Batman: Death by Design, out today from DC Comics, starts off as a pretty by-the-numbers story, but it turns into a fun and surprisingly resonant tale by the end. The real coup here is that Kidd and Taylor manage to instill in the reader the same fascination with architecture and the minds behind it that brought them to craft this comic in the first place. Reading this makes me want to explore the artistry behind the architecture in my own life.

And it’s all thanks to Batman.


Chris Lough is the production manager at Tor.com and should start looking into the very building he works in, for starters.

5 comments
Mordicai Knode
1. mordicai
I am a Piranesi & Hugh Ferriss geek, so I am so down.
Teresa Nielsen Hayden
2. tnh
Yessss. All this and Chip Kidd too, and a storyline that borrows heavily from the history of Penn Station.

Of course Batman works well with architecture. He always has. He and Superman both date from the period in which the roman noir pulp novel and early scientifiction were dividing the known universe into the World of Tomorrow and the City of Dreadful Night, mirror images of one another. Superman is native to one continuum, Batman to the other.

In Gotham, history piles up in grimy layers, and no problem ever completely goes away. Elaborately ornamented building fronts are matched with dirty alleyways out back. On the outskirts, there's an entire asylum devoted to criminally insane supervillains. It's Batman's home turf. Can you imagine him operating in Metropolis -- or worse, in the suburbs? It's impossible. Batman is practically an emergent property of Gotham City.
David Goldfarb
3. David_Goldfarb
I do find myself wondering what American cities have a unified design in their big buildings. Most of them are a patchwork of what was fashionable in different decades. (Maybe Washington DC? But that's a bit of a special case.)
Ian Johnson
5. IanPJohnson
@2: Batman's a little bit of a weird case when it comes to his hometown. I can't think of any other characters whose stories are so fundamentally linked to their settings. (Maybe Sherlock Holmes or Fafhrd and the Grey Mouser… but even so, I don't know that they're connected to London and Lankhmar the way Batman is connected to Gotham.)

@3: San Francisco has a pretty unified design for most of its smaller buildings, to the point where you can tell a typical San Francisco street from a street in any other city by just looking at the houses. But the big buildings (the TransAmerica Pyramid, 555 California Street, 44 Montgomery Street, etc.) could really be buildings in any other city. So that's not a good answer to your question.
Mordicai Knode
6. mordicai
5. IanPJohnson

Oh man, Lankhmar is totally linked to those two knobs. & off the top of my head, the whole host of Marvel is pretty tightly linked to New York City...to the point where them being on the West Coast is sort of inherently ridiculous (sorry Hawkeye). Spider-Man especially, right? Spider-Man needs Queens & Manhattan, for sure.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment