Fri
Jul 29 2011 4:40pm
Reader’s Guide to the New DC Universe: Frankenstein: Agent of S.H.A.D.E.

Reader’s Guide to the New DC Universe by Tim Callahan: Frankenstein: Agent of S.H.A.D.E.Each weekday, Tim will take a look at what we know about each of the upcoming 52 new comics from the September DC relaunch, one series at a time. Today: FRANKENSTEIN: AGENT OF S.H.A.D.E.!

The Concept and Characters: Imagine the 1931 Boris Karloff version of the Frankenstein monster acting as a rampaging, futuristically Conan-esque operative in the mold of Nick Fury, agent of S.H.I.E.L.D. Does that even make any sense?

How about if you take that character and then give him a squad of monsters, the “Creature Commandos” to lead, as they travel through necrotic dimensions and fight planetoid evils. Pretty hard to imagine, right?

Well, that’s what this comic is about, and it sounds like one of the most exciting concepts to come out of the DC relaunch.

This is no typical superhero comic. Nor is it your average monster comic. Or action/adventure series. Or space-hopping secret agent spectacle. It’s all of those things, pulling characters from Grant Morrison’s ambitious Seven Soldiers series from 2005-2006, and combining them with military monsters taken from a 1980 installment of Weird War Tales, and recombining them with a variation on an alternate reality take on the concept from this summer’s Flashpoint: Frankenstein and the Creatures of the Unknown.

The writer of that series, Jeff Lemire, is also the writer of this new ongoing title, and while Lemire will surely attempt to replicate some of the sense of wonder and gleeful energy that Morrison brought to his incarnation of Frankenstein and The Super Human Advanced Defense Executive (S.H.A.D.E.), Lemire has strengths of his own that will help flesh out the unusual characters at the center of this comic.

Really, though, the other 51 titles debuting in September will have a hard time competing with this series in terms of pure enthusiasm-of-concept. Frankenstein: Agent of S.H.A.D.E. has more manic ideas in its title than most of the comics will have in their entire first issue.

The Creative Team: Not only is the concept outrageous enough to be enticing, but the creative team for this series is one of the strongest DC has to offer. Writer Jeff Lemire, also scripting this fall’s Animal Man comic, has been doing critically-acclaimed (and Eisner-nominated) work on Superboy, and his previous work, whether for Top Shelf (like the Essex County Trilogy) or for his own self-published graphic novel (like Lost Dogs), has shown him to be a cartoonist with the power to craft emotionally resonant stories. He’s still just getting started as a pure writer (though he’s eternally drawing his own comics as well, with Sweet Tooth still coming out monthly from Vertigo, and another graphic novel for Top Shelf next year), but he’s already excellent.

Lemire has good story instincts, a passion for comics of the past without the apparent need to slavishly follow their style, and the ability to create evocative (and provocative) characters. It’s wonderful to see a guy of his talent on a knock-down crazy idea like this series.

Alberto Ponticelli is another Vertigo alum, coming off the cancelled Unknown Soldier series. Ponticelli draws with a stark crispness to his line, and in his Vertigo work he was able to alternate between gritty and lyrical, devastating and beautiful, as the situation warranted. His previous series was a work of realism bound in nightmares, and that approach would suit a tale of high-fantasy, like Frankenstein, amazingly well. Ponticelli will be able to ground the characters in a believable physicality, while he captures the insanity of their escapades.

Recommendation: Buy it, without hesitation. The absurdities of the superhero comic book marketplace (where anything, no matter how good, without an iconic character in the title sells a fraction of what the worst Batman comic sells) make this series worthy of immediate attention. It’s certainly worthy of that attention no matter what, with one of the best concepts of the year and one of the strongest creative teams working in mainstream comics, but it’s a series that will kick off its run already on life support. It’s going to be good, without a doubt, but it can’t afford the trade-waiters.

Buy every single issue of this one. You won’t regret it. And it will get to hang around, so we can all keep enjoying its viciously delightful, exceedingly well-crafted, madness.


Tim Callahan writes about comics for Tor.com, Comic Book Resources, Back Issue magazine, and his own Geniusboy Firemelon blog.

Readers Guide to the New DC Universe: ‹ previous | index | next ›
8 comments
Christopher Cabanillas
2. restiffbard
First, thanks for this guide series. I've been out of comics for years and years. The New 52 might not be everyone's cup of tea but it's exactly the sort of thing I've needed to get me back.

Frankenstein would never have been on my pull list except for my listening to the podcasts of the Comic-Con panels and your ringing endorsement.
Darren James
3. b8amack
Sounds like it would have been a great Wildstorm comic. Not sure it'll survive the mainstream DCU, though. Nothing but garbage in there, from the looks of it.
Darren James
4. b8amack
I forgot about reading this a few years back:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doc_Frankenstein

That was an awesome comic, but for some reason I didn't keep up with it. Probably the bs publication schedule. The original comic (Doc Frankenstein) like Red 5 Comics' Atomic Robo, did have a generous heaping of homage to Hellboy in it, but was its own comic. Still, this one seems a little TOO similar in content to the Darrow/Kroce comic. I call wtf-ery.
rob mcCathy
5. roblewmac
I don't know. I know i'm gonna take flack for this but strange for strange's sake often falls flat for me. What I'M suposed to think campy just comes off stupid.
ChadWhitley
6. ChadWhitley
Would you mind passing me some silverware? I don't like to eat crow with my hands.

This was one of the new titles that elicited a "Wha--?" from me when it was announced. There didn't seem to be a huge demand (even among the established fanbase) for new Frankenstein stories. So, you know...I actually made fun of this title.

Now it gets an endorsement from Tim Callahan. So I guess I'll be checking it out after all.

And I like my crow well-done.
ChadWhitley
7. coryj
I totally agree with Tim Callahan's review here.

Lemire is very talented. This book is probably the one worth buying out of the OCEAN of useless detritus DC's relaunch is trying to sell every one.
ChadWhitley
10. Amanda Pike
I kow this is only the comic books but you should know in the novel the creature was actually hyper-inteligent, did not have green skin, flat head, or bolts in his neck. He learned to dress himself almost immediately after his creation and could speak three languages fluently by the end of the novel. He was very well spoken and articulate. I sort of wish the comics would touch on the huge difference from what's in the novel to what people like you are apparently used to.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment