Tue
Jun 28 2011 5:11pm
Reading Joanna Russ: The Adventures of Alyx (1967-1970)

I’ve undertaken a project: reading all of the late, great Joanna Russ’s books in chronological order and sharing my thoughts on them in a series of posts. There’ll be some additional reference material where appropriate from books like Mendlesohn’s On Joanna Russ anthology and possibly Jean Cortiel’s Demand My Writing, too, but mostly just discussions of the books themselves.

To start, there’s The Adventures of Alyx. Technically, this isn’t the “first” book chronologically as it was actually published in 1986, but the stories themselves come from 1967-1970. Also, it does contain her first (short) novel, Picnic on Paradise, which was part of the Alyx story-cycle—so, it’s the first on the reading-list. The Alyx stories collected together create a sort of tapestry-novel, and that’s how I’ll be discussing them—as a complete book, The Adventures of Alyx. (I do wonder why it took sixteen years to publish the stories that so obviously made a complete tale in one book, but I suppose I’ll never know.)

What begins as Leiber-esque fantasy in the story “Bluestocking” (originally published as “The Adventuress”) traverses time and space into science fiction and finally metafictional commentary, creating a wonderful mosaic of stories that both entertain the reader in the conventional way—adventures, deadly danger, mysteries to solve—and also provoke thought about the roles of women in speculative fiction. It’s also open to quite a bit of reader interpretation, by the end.

For example, the first essay in Farah Mendlesohn’s On Joanna Russ collection is a piece by Gary K. Wolfe about these stories, “Alyx among the Genres.” I read the essay before actually reading the book, which gave me a strange angle on the stories—as if I’d been there before, but I hadn’t. The essay, in a way, set me up to read the Alyx stories as doubly fictional: stories produced by the young woman character of the final story, “The Second Inquisition,” who potentially represents a young Russ herself. It’s a brilliant essay that digs deep into the multilayered possibilities of the Alyx stories; I recommend giving it a read, too, if you have a taste for insightful criticism that picks at bits of the tale you never quite noticed.

Having seen the book in that light—the stories as stories written by a fictional character in her fictional imaginary universe, so that there are two layers of “fiction” in the text—I can’t unsee it; it seems perfect. (It’s not an insight original to me, though, so it’s only fair to credit Mr. Wolfe. Who can say if I would have put the pieces together, otherwise?)

Aside from that lovely, tricksy construction, there’s quite a bit to say about the Alyx stories. For one, they’re predominantly heterosexual, which came as a bit of a shock to me, having started my reading of Russ with quintessentially lesbian/queer texts (The Female Man, for example). I like it, though; straight women need to see themselves presented as capable and strong in fiction as much as queer women, and often see it even less, as if the addition of a male love interest saps the strength of a heterosexual female character. The frank discussions of sexuality, sensuality and women’s desire in The Adventures of Alyx revolve around Alyx herself, generally, and how she has dealt with and loved men—an abusive husband in one tale who drove her away to a pirate captain, who she eventually leaves, a lover in the SFnal story who is used against her by the antagonist, another lover when she is the potentially imaginary construction of the young woman in “The Second Inquisition,” and of course her intimate, emotional relationship with Machine in Picnic on Paradise.

There are men in Alyx’s life, but they are never her superiors—even with her abusive husband, it is made clear that she is the stronger of the two when she defeats him. In the best relationships, she is equal to them, and in the less developed, she’s the dominant figure. Alyx is the opposite of the women who would normally populate a swashbuckling adventure or SFnal survival story—she’s the hero, not the damsel in distress or the love interest. That is where I find the value of these stories/this book, as well as the reason I enjoyed them so much. It’s just awesome to read about a strong woman doing interesting, dangerous things, in control of her own life.

As previously mentioned, the first couple of Alyx stories are Leiber-esque fantasy (one story contains a reference to Fafhrd and the Grey Mouser, so it’s hardly by accident). The difference is that in place of the male hero, we have Alyx, tougher than hell and ready to fight when she needs to, but also capable of softness toward her estranged daughter as she remembers her and to the young woman in “Bluestocking” who she’s trying to help escape a bad arranged marriage. The development of Edarra, the young woman, provides a perfect parallel to the deadly intensity of Alyx—she starts out spoiled and whiny, but over the course of their trip, discovers sword-fighting and her own central desires. She becomes a real person, not simply a piece on a board to be moved about, and does so by developing a sense of independence. It’s a pleasure to watch unfold.

Really, I love the women of Alyx’s stories, most especially Alyx herself. What a refreshing surprise it is to see a woman hero of an adventure story, and later on in the more SFnal tales like “The Barbarian” to see that she’s not just a tough fighter but also remarkably intelligent as she works her way through the tricks of the man from the future who’s pretending to be a wizard. She’s competent, capable and genuinely well-developed as a person. Even today, there aren’t many women playing the protagonists’ role in stories like these.

Though, the shape and focus of the stories does change with the truly science-fiction tale, Picnic on Paradise, Russ’s first short novel. In this, Alyx is a time-traveler sent off to rescue a group of rich tourists trapped on a pleasure-planet which is the subject of a war. It’s a long, gruesome, upsetting story that yanks hard at the readers’ emotions—it’s no longer a playful adventure, but a survival tale where the best and brightest don’t make it, and the hero herself nears the breaking point. It puts Alyx through the wringer and allows the reader to see a depth of character hidden in the prior stories by their more superficial nature. It’s an engrossing read, and the survival-story is something Russ will come back to later in We Who Are About to… Nonetheless, it’s tonally very different from the other three stories, though Alyx remains recognizable.

The final story, “The Second Inquisition,” is where it gets weird. This is a contemporarily set story, about writing, reading, and the world of books for a young woman who is otherwise trapped, completely trapped, by her parents’ dysfunctional marriage, her suburban life and the expectations that dictate what she may do with her future. It’s the most directly feminist tale of the bunch, also; the others are feminist in that they present women as strong, equal humans capable of being the lead, but they are not as directly didactic as “The Second Inquisition” becomes. The discussions of race, gender and sexuality in this final tale are all intensely written through clipped, realistic dialogue, shown to the reader through the eyes of the young woman. In the end, the bit about daughters and granddaughters and whatnot seems to imply that the young woman is the creator of Alyx and the shaper of her, potentially her writer.

It’s a mind-bending ending that provokes quite a lot of thought and changes the way a reader looks at the other stories in The Adventures of Alyx, as not just tales written by Russ but stories written by a character who might be a young Russ or who might be another fictional creation—stories written by her as a means of escape.

I deeply enjoyed reading these stories, separately and as a whole; they provide both flat-out entertainment—they really are fun and exciting—and thoughtful commentary that’s likely to stick with the reader, as it did me, for some while after finishing the book. The writing is, of course, phenomenal; I probably don’t even need to bother to say that.

The next book, however—And Chaos Died—provoked a totally different response from me, as I’ll explain next time.


Brit Mandelo is a multi-fandom geek with a special love for comics and queer literature. She can be found on Twitter and Livejournal.

12 comments
Pamela Adams
1. Pam Adams
Yay- a new reading/discussion list, and to be honest, I haven't read much of Russ' work. Alyx is on order through my university library.

Can you give us a chronological list so we can get ahead on the reading?
Brit Mandelo
2. BritMandelo
@Pam Adams

Ah, yes, good idea.

Here we go:

1. The Adventures of Alyx (1967-1970/1983*)
2. And Chaos Died (1970)
3. The Female Man (1975)
4. We Who Are About To… (1977)
5. The Two of Them (1978)
6. Kittatinny: A Tale of Magic (1978)
7. On Strike Against God (1980)
8. How to Suppress Women's Writing (1983)
9. The Zanzibar Cat (1983)
10. Extra(Ordinary) People (1984)
11. Magic Mommas, Trembling Sisters, Puritans & Perverts (1985)
12. The Hidden Side of the Moon (1988)
13. To Write Like a Woman (1995)
14. What Are We Fighting For? (1998)
15. The Country You Have Never Seen (2007)
kev mcveigh
3. kev mcveigh
Picnic On Paradise was published as an individual short novel. I have this edition with a typically bad cover http://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B002JJ6KQS?ie=UTF8&force-full-site=1

I think Picnic does work on its own, but all the stories gain from their juxtaposition in Adventures. Not only do they create a bigger picture but they begin to engage with each other in a way Russ would take further in later novels.
Brit Mandelo
4. BritMandelo
@Kev McVeigh

Oh, yes, Picnic does work on its own--absolutely.

(Where to start this series was something I spent a while thinking about--with Picnic on its own, then get to Adventures of Alyx later, was a thought; but then this way seemed more logical.)
Bob Blough
5. Bob
I've read all of Russ's fiction except The Two of Them. I was so disappointed in We Who Are About To... that I just didn't get to her last novel. Her work is brilliant and difficult at the same time. I like that, but it does sometimes mean I have to wait for the "Reading Russ Moment" to happen for me to really enjoy them. I kinda have this same reaction with Gene Wolfe - who is one of my favorite SF/F authors of all time.
Wesley Parish
6. Aladdin_Sane
FWLIW, the first of Russ' stories I read was The Adventures of Alyx; the second was the Whileaway story in the Dangerous Visions or Again Dangerous Visions anthology. I've read a few of her books - We Who Are About To .. and The Two Of Them, I felt, were cri de coeur novels - and I did get angry while reading The Two Of Them: there's this young woman who has addicted herself to an older man, forced herself onto him, made him responsible for her - then when she starts behaving erratically, she goes ahead and shoots him for, believe it or not, taking responsibility for her. Which struck me as intolerably self-indulgent and immature, while displaying some undoubtedly fashionable despair over the relationship of the two sexes.

Alyx I read as a wordsmith's display of delight and power in wordsmithying. And an ironical tribute to one of the founders of modern Sword and Sorcery and probably one of her love/hate inspirations.
kev mcveigh
7. Eugene R.
A good beginning for a worthy project! I look forward to more (re)readings of Ms. Russ's powerful and personal works.

One thing that always sticks with me regarding her writing: the evocative titles that she uses. "I Thought She Was Afeard Till She Stroked My Beard" (in The Adventures of Alyx), "When It Changed" (in The Zanzibar Cat), "I Had Vacantly Crumpled It into My Pocket ... But, By God, Eliot, It Was a Photograph From Life!" (in The Hidden Side of the Moon). Her titles seem like snippets of poems or songs.

Which makes it curiously disappointing that her first book was titled Picnic *in* Paradise, but was changed by the publisher to Picnic *on* Paradise, losing the ironic comment in exchange for the more blatant science fictional plug.
Peter D. Tillman
8. PeteTillman
Who did the cover on the ed. you show above?

Pretty sure I have the same one, but it's 500+ miles away.

Look forward to more Russ stuff!

Cheers -- Pete Tillman
Brit Mandelo
9. BritMandelo
@Bob

You're right, Russ and Wolfe are both tough to read for long stretches - I tend to need gaps between them.

@Aladdin_Sane

The Two of Them is a book I have a weird emotional reaction to, also.

So many of her books, like Alyx, work on the level of wordsmithying, as you said--commentaries within commentaries, lines containing three different allusions at once, etc. I always get the feeling from Alyx that she did like Leiber, too.

@Eugene R.

I hadn't mentioned that, and I should have, but yes: her titles are awesome. She and James Tiptree Jr. both tended to have some crazy-awesome titles, with so much resonance.

@Pete Tillman

I'm not certain, either--hrmph. Maybe the internet at large can answer who the artist is...? Anybody?

I hope you enjoy the posts!
Teresa Nielsen Hayden
10. tnh
Brit: You're right. Joanna was a fan of Leiber's writing.
Pamela Adams
11. Pam Adams
Alyx herself seemed to be a fan- in one story she comments on having dated a barbarian- 'Fafnir, no it was Fafh-.'
Brit Mandelo
12. BritMandelo
@tnh

Cool! I thought so.

@Pam Adams

Yes, that bit is one of the most direct references, and it made me giggle.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment