Jul 7 2010 11:00am

Welcome to the Malazan Re-read of the Fallen on

Welcome to a new blog series on, the Malazan Read and Re-read of the Fallen! Your hosts are Bill (reading the series for a second time) and Amanda (reading it for the first time), and in the coming months we will read, re-read, discuss, summarize, analyze, scratch our heads in confusion, wonder out loud, possibly argue (courteously), occasionally criticize (also courteously), marvel, and at times (we’re sure) bow to the superior knowledge of’s readers as we attempt to dissect the epic fantasy world created Steven Erikson and Ian C. Esslemont. As we finish each book in the series, both writers will appear to help us do a wrap-up!

If you think you saw an earlier intro post about a Malazan Re-read going on here at Tor involving Bill and his fellow reviewer Stefan, you aren’t crazy. Due to some unforeseen circumstance that precluded Stefan from having the time needed for such a big project, he had to sadly bow out, though I’m sure he’ll join us in the comments section. Luckily, Amanda, their fellow reviewer, was gracious (or crazy) enough to step in.

So, starting with book one, Gardens of the Moon, we’re basically thrown into the deep: a world with a 300,000-year history, several original non-human races, and a unique and complex magic system.  Subsequent volumes offer up Dramatic Personae lists and glossaries that cover several pages per volume, and multiple storylines that aren’t always told in chronological fashion: book 2 is set on an entirely different continent from book 1, book 3 picks up where book 1 left off, book 4 continues book 2, and just when you think there’s a pattern developing, book 5 starts an entirely new storyline. With so many plot strands and hundreds of characters, some of whom change names as they die and get resurrected or die and become gods (as one character says “does nothing dead ever go away around here?”), there is a LOT of material here to keep track of.

If, like Bill, you picked up most of these novels as they were released, quite a few years may have gone by since you first read the earlier books. You may have found yourself reading one of the later novels and recognizing the name of a character, but having no idea of who they were or exactly what they did earlier. Or, if you’re a first time reader like Amanda, you will be painfully aware that seemingly the rest of the fantasy world has picked up this series and raved about it—and hence it is high time you read the books to see what all the fuss is about!

To be clear, neither of us is holding ourselves up as some sort of Malazan expert (especially Amanda, who expects to be going “huh?!” a lot). We’re not promising all the answers (we’re aiming for 82.7% of them) and we’re sure we’ll even make some mistakes (*gasp*). In a nutshell, we’re going to muddle through this together with you, and hopefully with your help we’ll all achieve a better if not complete grasp of this somewhat daunting material.

So, here’s the plan: we’ve broken up the books in parts of roughly 100 to 150 pages each. The page count is based on the US mass-market editions, but we’ll use chapter divisions as a yardstick so you can follow along regardless of which edition you have. We are planning one article per week—a leisurely pace, so as many people as possible can read along and still otherwise be productive members of society. This means that we’re probably going to take at least a year to cover the books that have been published so far—and by the time we’re done, The Crippled God will hopefully be out, so we can lead right into the final volume.

In each section, we’ll present a summary of events and some analysis based on what we’ve read up to that point, and then open the floor to discussion. We hope you’re looking forward to this as much as we are!

Here’s a bit more about Bill: I live in Rochester NY with my wife and 8-year-old son and I’ve been reading fantasy/science fiction nearly as long as I can remember, beginning in primary school with the Danny Dunn series (hmm, speaking of a re-read...) and moving on to The Borrowers, Narnia, Andre Norton, and that frozen-in-my-mind moment when my father handed me a copy of The Hobbit in the Sibleys’ bookstore and said “I think you’ll like this.” I love sprawling, lengthy, complex works, so long as the length is necessitated by the complexity; I’m not a big fan of a good 350-page novel buried in a 750-page book. I look for strong characterization probably more than anything else—give me some characters to care about and I’ll go pretty far with them (of course, w/ Erikson that may not be very far as he’s so fond of killing them off. Then again, he’s equally fond of bringing them back so it’s always farther than you think.)

Along with Erikson, some of my favorite current authors are Daniel Abraham, Brandon Sanderson, China Mieville, and Catherynne Valente (for a more full sense of my tastes, you can check out my reviews at Beyond reading and reviewing fantasy, I write short stories and essays, play ultimate frisbee, teach as an adjunct English instructor at several local colleges, and annoy my wife by complaining about Lost as she’s watching it (with the finale I’ll now have to find a different way of annoying her—my work is never done).

And some info from Amanda: I live in Portsmouth, UK with a houseful of books and two utterly madcap cats (no, I am not a crazy cat lady—yet). As with Bill, I have been reading fantasy pretty much since The Brothers Grimm and Hans Christian Andersen. My dad started me off on C.S. Lewis and Tolkien, and from there I embarked on all the fantasy fiction I could find! My particular early memory is being read to out of a beautiful hardback version of The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe, and feeling entranced by the idea of worlds beyond ours. Embarrassingly, I also spent half my time after that in the wardrobe just in case...

I have read an enormous amount of good fantasy fiction and bad fantasy fiction, and some of my favourites include Charles de Lint, China Mieville, Sharon Shinn, and David Gemmell. As well as contributing reviews and a regular World Wide Wednesday post to, I also review for my own site (covering more genres than just speculative), Vector Reviews and Hub magazine. Although this all seems to take up an ever-increasing amount of time, I also manage to shoehorn in playing field hockey and an obscene amount of cinema trips.

Paul Weimer
1. PrinceJvstin
Malazan is one of my favorite series. I am looking forward to this re-read.
Kat Hooper
2. Kat_at_Fantasy_Literature
Okay, I'm in!
I wish this series was on audio, but I'll make an effort to find some time to sit down with my hardback copy of GOTM which I have had sitting on my shelf for years. Never got around to it!
Lord Widebottom
3. Lord Widebottom
The Malazon Books are so Information Dense that they really reward re-reading, even after my third time I still picked up on things I had missed before. Be patient, Amanda :) You are going to read a lot of things that will not make much sense until you are a few books in because of the parallel story-lines of the novels. Just hang in there, it's well worth it :)
Lord Widebottom
4. Steven Diamond
Lord Widebottom is right on the money. Gotta love this stuff. Once upon a time I managed a bookstore, and the Malazan series was my #1 recommended series. More happens in one novel in Erikson and & Esllemont's stuff than in other FULL series by other authors.

What I have come to appreciate most in the Malazan novels is the characterization. These guys make us invested in the characters so effortlessly.

Amanda, you are in for such a good time.

--Steve Diamond
Elitist Book Reviews
Chuk Goodin
5. Chuk
Excellent choice for a re-read series (but Danny Dunn would be, too, for totally different reasons). I don't know that I have the time and energy to actually follow along in the books, but I'll be following the posts.

(Not that the books don't reward it, but I'm in general not much of a re-reader myself and there is a lot to re-read there...)
John Mann
6. jcmnyu
I'd love to start this series as I've heard good things about it, but I was disappointed to see that it isn't available as an eBook for the Nook. It is available for the Kindle. Any reason why the eBook would be for sale at Amazon and not Barnes and Noble?
Lord Widebottom
7. William Hunter
First, just to get it out of the way...the history of 'the Malazan world', that is, the world upon which the vast majority of the story takes place, extends much, much farther than 300 000 years. That date roughly marks the occasion of the Imass ritual. Prior to this event, we have the evolution of the Eres to the Imass and eons of time, with Jaghut, Forkrul Assail and K'Chain civilizations. Think of a time scale similar to our own world with more activity.

Anyway, this is a worthy effort and I can say that Gardens is the most re-readable of the books in my opinion. There's a unique atmosphere to this book and it's well-worth re-visiting in depth.
Jason Holdeman
8. jasonholdeman
In the course of this re-read, will you also be reviewing the adjunct works (Baudelaine and Korbal Broach, Knight of Knives, and Return of the Crimson Guard)?
9. Abalieno
I noticed that in the list you put "Night of Knives" between the first and second book, and I'd heartily suggest you move it after the fourth book.

The story flows much better that way, and readers can avoid terrible spoilers.
Chase Collins
10. Quick Ben
This is an amazing opportunity! I have made it as far as Reaper's Gale in the series. However some events have caused me to set it aside for a while. I decided after trying to get back into the book that I was going to do a re-read sometime, cause I was completely lost. So I am very exited about this. Definitely a great idea.
Mani A
11. sn0wcrash
Great to hear this. I found the last two Malazan books really hard going as I was getting bogged down in the minutae of the world & characters. Looking forward to this.
Amanda Rutter
12. ALRutter
I'm really glad to see you all being so welcoming and some of you jumping on board to either re-read or first-read this series!
Travis Nelsen
13. Zangred
I just started re-reading the series a few months ago and am about to finish up The Bonehunters (book 6). Looking forward to reading about the series here, maybe it will clear up a few of those "huh?" moments I've had.
Lord Widebottom
14. Naina Redhu
I've re-read all books before Dust of Dreams about 6 times each and I have a lot of loose ends to tie. I can't get myself to re-read Dust though. This is an awesome idea.
Lord Widebottom
15. Looking
Cool intro by the people doing this reread. Is there a link to the actual reread, though? (I'm sorry if I overlooked it).
Steven Halter
17. stevenhalter
Go to the main page of and the reread link is on the right hand side--spam eater ate my link.
Lord Widebottom
19. Eliesar
i own all books by erikson malaz, and will own all books by Esslemont, and can you say me how to best to begin to read them.
Steven Halter
20. stevenhalter
On the main malazan reread portion of this site is the order in which we are doing the reread. (You can find the link on the right hand side of the page).
Start with Gardens of the Moon. There have been some comments that following along with the reread as you start to read is useful.
Lord Widebottom
21. Eliesar
But what do you think, of this order.
1 Garden of the moon
2 Deadhouse Gates
3 Memories of ice
4 house of chains
5 midnight tides
6 night of knifes
7 the bonehunters
8 reaper´s gale
9 the return of the krimson guard
10 toll the hounds
11 dust of dreams
12 stone wielder
13 the crippled god
Steven Halter
22. stevenhalter
It's a fine order. The one on the main portion was recommended by Steven Erikson and Ian Esslemont and is the order the reread is going in.
By reading Night of Knives earlier, you glimpse a few things you wouldn't see until later. That's not really a problem or anything.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment