Tue
Apr 20 2010 1:51pm
George Scithers (1929-2010)

George Scithers died yesterday, and I want to speak well of him.

George Scithers was a competent, hard-working member of the SF community for decades, and richly deserved the Life Achievement Award he was given by the World Fantasy Convention in 2002.

Young George Scithers was a Colonel in the US Army and studied at West Point in a class taught by Robert A. Heinlein’s older brother.

George Scithers was responsible more than anyone else for the rise of heroic fantasy between 1959 and 1979, through the medium of his fanzine, Amra, in which he encouraged the serious discussion of the form. He won the Hugo Award for best fanzine in 1964 and 1968.

He began a small press of distinction (Owlswick Press, 1973 onward). His bestselling title was probably The Necronomicon, limited, bound in red leather with introductory notes by L. Sprague De Camp. His funniest was probably To Serve Man, a cookbook. Perhaps the most important was Avram Davidson’s Adventures in Unhistory. He wrote the first guide to chairing a science fiction convention in 1965, after chairing the 1963 Worldcon in Washington, DC, Discon I.

George Scithers was the founding editor of Isaac Asimov’s Science Fiction Magazine (1977-82), and grew it to the largest circulation in the field in its day while he was editor, and following that was the editor of Amazing Stories until 1986. He won the Hugo for Best Editor in 1978 and 1980. He actually tried to follow the good parts of the John W. Campbell editorial tradition as a magazine editor, and outsold Analog for a time. He notably encouraged young writers, including, in the early years of Asimov’s, Darrell Schwietzer, Somtow Sucharitkul and John M. Ford.

Later George Scithers was the publisher of Weird Tales for many years (with Darrell Schweitzer and John Betancourt). He was a literary agent (the Owlswick Agency) in the late 1980s and 1990s. I generally found him a pleasure to deal with as a businessman.

We were not more than professional friends, but I enjoyed that. He was sometimes a silly man, given to wearing very loud sport jackets, and often greeted me with “woof!” Or occasionally “Woof, woof!” He was eccentric, intelligent, and seemed to me committed to the maintenance and improvement of the SF & Fantasy field.


David Hartwell is an editor for Tor Books.

7 comments
Marcus W
1. toryx
I'm sorry to hear of the loss of another outstanding contributor to the genre. Thanks for the great tribute.
Clark Myers
2. ClarkEMyers
Did indeed follow the good parts of the Campbell tradition.

Deserves to be fondly remembered for some immortal (at least on the web) words:-

... Ours is only one opinion, but it is possible for us to be right, and our comments might help you to do better with your next story. Again: we reject pieces of paper; we cannot and will not reject you. We pay ... on acceptance. emphasis added

It is not I think for encouraging the names cited that the greater honor is due but for being fondly remembered by folks who themselves are forgotten or who went another way.
Kevin Standlee
3. Kevin Standlee
I was happy that I got to share head-table space on a panel with him at MilPhil when he was the 2001 Worldcon's Fan GoH. Not only was he instrumental in my young reading habits -- I was a subscriber to IASFM in his editorial days, and let it lapse after he left because the stories were no longer to my taste -- but he was also and electric railroad enthusiast like me, and, perhaps most esoterically, he was like me a past parliamentarian of the World Science Fiction Society's Business Meeting. I first met him at my first convention -- the 1984 Worldcon -- after the Business Meeting where I expressed admiration for his work on the head table there as well as with his magazine; he gave me a copy of the submision guidelines for IASFM.

It's not as though I knew him well, but we were in many ways kindred spirits in Fandom.
Kevin Standlee
4. Missy Pavlat Koslosky
I grew up in fandom in the DC area (late 60's-mid 80's), and George Scithers is one of the fans who was always like part of the family. When I heard that he'd died, it was, in some ways, like losing another piece of my father. In addition to his professional and fannish credentials, George was a good, kind man, and I'm so sorry that he's gone.
Kelly McCullough
5. KellyMcCullough
He was a grand old man and I will miss him. Along with Darrell Schweitzer at Weird Tales he bought my first story, and several more thereafter.
Kevin Standlee
6. Jim Henry III
Possibly the first hardback books I bought new were Adventures in Unhistory and The Adventures of Doctor Eszerhazy by Avram Davidson, by mail-order from Owlswick Press. A little later, I wrote Avram Davidson a fan letter in care of George Scithers, and got a letter from him telling me that Avram had just died recently -- so this must have been late 1993.

I've bought a number of very well-made books from small presses in the years since then, but Adventures in Unhistory still impresses me with its design (not to mention its contents). At the time, I'm fairly sure the only books Avram Davidson had in print were those two from Owlswick; I suspect George Scithers thus deserves some of the credit for the more recent Avram Davidson revival with the spate of new collections and novel reprints in the late 1990s and early 2000s.
Kevin Standlee
7. Rosemary Kirstein.
George Scithers bought my first short story, for Asimov's magazine, way back in 1982. I met him once, briefly, at a convention a few years later. He did not remember me, but no matter -- he's the guy who put me in the same issue as Greg Benford, Connie Willis, John M. Ford, along with a then-brand-new story by Asimov himself.

He read what I wrote and liked it, at a time when I hardly knew myself as a writer. He gave me money for it, which made me a professional. He indicated the sort of people who I should consider my colleagues (other writers, GOOD writers). Helped me see where I should be headed.

I'm so sorry he's gone.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment