Fri
Mar 5 2010 5:31pm
Pulp Lives, Again (But For How Long?)

When Max Phillips and I sat down over sushi and plum wine in the winter of 2001 and came up with the idea for Hard Case Crime, it was not with the intention of becoming the new godfathers of pulp fiction—or the midwives of a pulp rebirth.

We’d just noticed that it had been a while since we’d seen any old-fashioned, pulp-styled paperback novels in bookstores and we missed them. 

So we decided to create some our own. We figured maybe we’d find some publisher willing to bring out five or six of the things, and that would be the end of it. Sixty-three books later, Hard Case Crime is (to my amazement) still trundling along, turning out lurid editions of novels old and new. And in the years since we published our first titles we’ve seen any number of other publishers dip a toe in the pulp waters as well.  

From time to time I wonder why—why pulp fiction keeps coming back, so many decades after its origin, and also why it keeps going away. It’s like the literary equivalent of cicadas, returning every handful of years to sing its siren song and then vanish once more.

Wouldn’t you think (he asked rhetorically) there’d be an endless appetite for punchy, short novels with gripping plot hooks, plenty of action, and gorgeous painted covers featuring attractive characters with not too many clothes on? I know I never grow tired of these things. But readers as a whole seem to have only a limited appetite for them. Actually, that’s not quite right—it seems to be an endlessly renewing appetite, but one that quickly gets sated. You see a new enterprise launch and flourish for a few years, and then the novelty wears off and readers move on to other things. Then, when they’ve gone without for too many years, they always seem glad to see pulp fiction return.  

The last major rebirth (before we came along) was in the 1980s, when Barry Gifford launched the Black Lizard series in the crime fiction genre and, in sf, Tor came up with “Tor Doubles”, their tip of the hat to the great Ace Doubles of yore. Then there was nothing for about a cicada cycle. And now — there’s plenty, once again.

Does this mean we’re due for another pulp crash, like the collapse of the dot-com bubble? With pulp writers forced to hock their battered Underwoods to pay the rent on their SRO flats and painters reduced to copying Old Masters for hooch money? Hopefully not. But if like me you’re a lover of this particular strain of pop culture ephemera, I’d encourage you to grab it while it’s out there. Remember why they call it ‘ephemera.’ Before too much longer you might be paying collectors’ prices for it on eBay while, in the bookstores, shelves are bare.

(Full disclosure: I benefit if you do “grab it while it’s out there,” at least if any Hard Case Crime books wind up in your shopping cart.  But hell, I may also be the one selling the overpriced copies to you on eBay next year...)


Charles Ardai is the Edgar and Shamus Award winning author of novels such as Fifty-To-One, Little Girl Lost, and Songs of Innocence as well as founder and editor of Hard Case Crime and its companion series, The Adventures of Gabriel Hunt. In a previous life, he created the Internet service Juno.

14 comments
Mary R
1. MaryArrrr
As someone who bought lots of Black Lizard in the day (and Hard Case now), what I think you are doing right is mixing old and new. The pulp writers were prolific, meaning that there is a lot of stuff that probably should be considered "completist only." The boom tends to end when people hear how amazing Black Lizard books are, but end up with a minor work by a secondary writer, instead of THE GRIFTERS. It's not just pulp, the same thing happened with the Virago Modern Classics. At first you could grab any one and it'd be great, but at a certain point, you'd have to start doing research to find out if it was something you'd be interested in - no longer an impulse purchase.

This is said as someone who has the complete run of the Ballantine Cornell Woolrich reissues.
Charles Ardai
2. CharlesArdai
Those Ballantine Woolrichs are something special for the gorgeous Larry Schwinger covers alone. Well worth owning a set even if some of the books themselves aren't pure gold.
rosena
3. rosena
I have read every book in the Hard Case series and was even lucky to win one signed by Charles himself! This genre will always have faithful followers like myself. One day I can only hope that my grandaughters find my collection of "pulp" and realize how much fun it is to escape to somewhere out of the norm. This is FUN reading and the cover art is always a treat. I hope that I can look forward to HCC for many years to come.
Gray Woodland
4. Greyhame
That Doyle cover caught me completely unsuspecting in Forbidden Planet the other month. It was more than a minute before I'd recovered enough of the power of speech to explain to my companion what all the pointing and jaw-dropping were about. I still don't really think she got it. Pure class!

But the reason I'm really glad you posted this is here: The Dead Man's Brother, one last unlooked-for gift from the great Roger Zelazny. I owe you big-time for that one. My only regret is that my Dad - the compleat Zelazny fan - clocked out a couple of months too soon to read it. I read it for his birthday instead. Turns out, it deserved it.

Thank you! I shall be keeping the beady eye out.
Dr. Kirtland C Peterson
5. catsongs
Wouldn’t you think (he asked rhetorically) there’d be an endless appetite for punchy, short novels with gripping plot hooks, plenty of action, and gorgeous painted covers featuring attractive characters with not too many clothes on?

Yes!

Love the covers. My wife finds lurid ones from time to time on postcards and makes presents of them to me! Love 'em!
Charles Ardai
6. CharlesArdai
We both owe our thanks to Roger's son, Trent, who brought the manuscript of THE DEAD MAN'S BROTHER to my attention. It really was like a gift from the Beyond, to get to hear Roger's voice again.
rosena
7. Steve Oerkfitz
I have read about half the Hardcase books and have like most of the-the Christa Faust being my favorite. Now if someone would only reprint some John D. MacDonald. Only his Travis McGee are in print.
rosena
8. peachy
@ 4 Hehe. The first time I saw that cover I said, "nah, the title has to be a coincidence." Then I took a closer look, and... wow. I wonder how many readers were disappointed to find out they'd just bought a Sherlock Holmes mystery with absolutely no lascivious elements whatsoever? I suspect "the Bodymaster" was a *real* disappointment.
Charles Ardai
9. CharlesArdai
@8: In case you're curious, here's what the book's back cover says...

YEARS AGO, A P.I. OUT OF CHICAGO
BROUGHT JUSTICE TO A DIRTY TOWN.

NOW HE’S GOING TO PAY.

A sawed-off shotgun blast to the face leaves one man dead — and reveals a secret that has pursued another across an ocean and set the world’s most ruthless criminal on his trail. The man needs the help of a great detective...but could even Sherlock Holmes save him now?
Rob Munnelly
10. RobMRobM
I did the double take as well. VoF is my favorite Holmes. I thought this was an homage rather than the real thing. Interesting....
rosena
11. peachy
Hrmph. The back cover is disappointingly straightforward given the front - aside from, you know, blowing both of the twist endings.
Charles Ardai
12. CharlesArdai
Ah, well. Does it help that the portion after the elipsis appears in italics? (Something I don't know how to reproduce in this site's comment system.) Quite a lot of people who've picked it up tell me they still didn't figure out that Sherlock Holmes would actually appear in the novel. They thought it was a *rhetorical* Sherlock Holmes...

As for blowing the twist endings, I'm not sure. I think it might only truly blow them if you already know what they are. Anyway, it's hard for me to feel TOO terrible about it - I think the statute of limitations on spoiler alerts has got to be 90 years or less...
Gray Woodland
13. Greyhame
As to twist endings... actually, the traditional answer to blurbs like,

"Can even Mickey Murino duck around Don Silvio's ruthless carabinieri, defeat the daffy demigods of Lost Cwacossa, and persuade hardboiled femme fatale Sheelba No-Eyes to remove her horrible hoodie?"

is, in fact, "Bet you ten bob he can!"

Sometimes, you just have to take some people's ten bob.
Jared Kardos
14. darkknightjared
Yeah, short, pulpy works is one of those things I am surprised that they seem to ebb in popularity in. I'd like to think that with all the different ways we can access books nowadays, there'd always at least be a thriving market for those who look for it.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment