Tue
Mar 30 2010 4:17pm
Battlefield Earth Writer Apologizes: Let the Healing Begin

There’s really no such thing as “good news” when it comes to Battlefield Earth, the hulking, bloated juggernaut of Scientology-fueled cinematic mayhem that flickered briefly across movie screens in 2000 on its downward plunge to the stank-ridden pantheon of  The Most Soul-Crushing Movies Ever Made.

Those of us who actually managed to sit through the entirety of the film will never get those two precious hours of our lives back, and won’t ever look at actors like John Travolta and Forest Whitaker again without some sense of betrayal, and perhaps an uncontrolled desire for face-punching. Some of us wake in the night screaming about bewildering alien dreadlocks, as the sound of scenery being mercilessly chewed still echoes through the dark of our damaged psyches...

At this point, nothing short of a Hot Tub Time Machine or a frontal lobotomy can truly undo the damage Travolta and his cronies inflicted in bringing L. Ron Hubbard’s dubious vision to stilted, unwatchable life, but at least one man is finally owning up to his part in the mammoth, tripledecker suckfest that scars our collective consciousness to this day. In Sunday’s New York Post, screenwriter J.D. Shapiro has written a two-page apology for penning “the suckiest movie ever” (his words—but you know he’s right).

Shapiro goes on to explain that he only got involved with Scientology as a way to pick up women (charming), and that his original script was completely rewritten by Travolta and his associates, churning out the hot, Xenu-approved mess we all came to know and loathe—the film Travolta apparently envisioned as “the Schindler’s List of sci-fi.” (Seriously, Travolta? Ugh). Shapiro was then fired, but he recently turned up to accept his Razzie® award for “Worst Picture of the Decade,” leading to his apology (which you can read in its entirety here). Strange days.

Oddly enough, before this debacle, J.D. Shapiro was best known for writing Robin Hood: Men in Tights, which I admittedly have a soft spot for—it’s Mel Brooks’s last funny film, and it has a Patrick Stewart cameo! In any case, Brooks once defined the difference between comedy and tragedy in the following manner: “Tragedy is when I cut my finger. Comedy is when you walk into an open sewer and die.” All I know is, somewhere far beyond the two, there exists a fetid, pointless limbo called Battlefield Earth, and it truly stinks on ice. I guess it’s kind of nice to hear that the writer thinks so, too.


Bridget McGovern is a lit nerd, a film geek, and a complete pop culture junkie. She enjoys David Bowie, roller coasters, and Mel Brooks more than anyone probably should. Dislikes: Battlefield Earth, sharp sticks in the eye.

26 comments
Marcus W
1. toryx
I'm so happy that I was able to end 2000 with my sanity intact by avoiding this movie completely (and ever after).

I didn't even know that Forest Whitaker was in it.
Fake Name
2. ThePendragon
I've been considering watching this. Is it worth it in a kind of, It's SO BAD you have to see it, kind of way? Or should I avoid it at all cost?
Barry T
3. blindillusion
That was Forest Whitaker? Really? How odd....

I sat through about forty-five minutes of this "movie" thinking WTF about every other second.

Talk about one of those, "They should burn the negative" kind of things.

Pen. Not at all. It's in the, "Might as well use the DVD as a Frisbee" category...that's about the only way the disc is worth anything.
Jason Lyman
4. jlyman
Loved the book. Love the story. The screenwriting ruined it all. There were a couple high points, if I remember right, but I was very disappointed. I had such high expectations and it didn't even come close.
Richard Fife
5. R.Fife
I saw this in the theater. I had actually forgotten enough of it that I was starting to fondly remember it as a "possibly not entirely bad movie". Just those 8 minutes of RiffTrax have resurfaced many suppressed, painful memories.
Bridget McGovern
6. BMcGovern
Poor Forest Whitaker--if it helps, he's apparently expressed regret at having participated in the film. And happily, his career hasn't suffered any; I guess he's done a pretty decent job of distancing himself as much as possible from the fallout...

I'm a huge fan of campy movies, and I was pretty excited to mock this when it first came out on DVD...I was expecting it to be like Plan 9 to the Nth degree: hilariously bad. Unfortunately it was just bad-bad: we didn't even make it through the first hour that time. Battlefield Earth is kind of like a cinematic vacuum sucking all joy and light and hope out of existence...I'm with @blindillusion on this one. If I were going to watch the whole thing again, it would have to be the RiffTrax enhanced version. And maybe a large baby pool filled with tequila, to take the edge off.

@jlyman Good to know you recommend the book--it's probably gotten a terrible rap thanks to this train wreck, which is really a shame.
Arachne Jericho
7. arachnejericho
@ThePendragon #2 -

Unfortunately, Battlefield Earth falls into the realm of "It's So Bad, It's Horrible." It takes ALL—your time, your enjoyment, I swear even your life force. And it gives nothing back.

It's kind of like Manos: The Hands of Fate in that way.
Ian Tregillis
8. ITregillis
I managed to sit through this thing twice. Granted, the second time was only possible thanks to Rifftrax, but the fact remains I paid money to see this.

I knew it was going to be bad -- that was sort of the point of the exercise -- but sheesh.

Having been a devoted fan of MST3K, I can easily think of worse movies than Battlefield Earth. But none of those were major studio releases.
Andrew Gray
9. madogvelkor
I thought "Mission to Mars" was worse. But maybe 2000 was just a bad year for SF movies.
Arachne Jericho
10. arachnejericho
I dug around one of my favorite sites, TVTropes, and found this wonderful page devoted to Battlefield Earth.

@madogvelkor #9 -

I think Misson to Mars is still better than Battlefield Earth, because the former (a) isn't on a slanted angle throughout the entire film, and (b) isn't shot through pink, purple, blue, yellow, and green color filters.
Richard Fife
11. R.Fife
Ahem, xkcd explains the relationship of bad movies and awesomeness.
peachy
12. peachy
I recall reading about the case of a tenth century French baron who stole a church's altar vessels. To expatiate this sin, he was assigned a triple Jerusalem pilgrimage - by land, barefoot, in chains, with the final stage of the third round-trip also involving two burly men with whips.

That was an apology.
Bridget McGovern
13. BMcGovern
@R. Fife: NICE! I love that xkcd (although I also love the Star Wars Holiday Special--own the DVD and everything. My tolerance for camp is disturbingly high :)

@arachnejericho: Thanks for the link--that page is spectacular. "The Psychlos are a merry bunch." :) So true.

@ITregillis I completely agree with your MST-inspired distinction. Is Red Zone Cuba technically worse than Battlefield Earth? Probably--but it has plenty of excuses in terms of budgets and other constraints. B.E. is just gratuitously awful, when it didn't have to be. It boggles the mind.

@peachy: Indeed. I like your style.
Fake Name
14. ThePendragon
Is it weird that all of your insistence to avoid this just makes me want to watch this THAT much more?

Maybe Tor could let me host a Battlefield Earth Re-Watch? :O
Marc Houle
15. MightyMarc
That was the best non-apologetic apology I've ever seen. If I were going to make a movie, I'd hire him to write it.
Soni Pitts
16. sonipitts
What's truly horrifying is the realization that to create that Rifftrax, the boys had to sit through that film over and over and over until they'd written, practiced and perfected each and every joke. Seriously, they deserve a frakking medal. Or a humanitarian lobotomy.
Alex Brown
17. Milo1313
At least he has the balls to apologize for that monstrosity that now permanently plagues my Action 6 TV network on weekday nights at 3am. If only Michael Bay would apologize for Transformers then I could die happy.

R.Fife @ 11: As a Rocky Whore myself, I would argue that every bad movie that involves transvestites (preferably singing transvestites) immediately crosses into awesome territory.
peachy
18. Mithril Wisdom
The weird thing is that I googled up this movie a few days before I saw this post. I'm glad to have missed it entirely when it first came out, but after reading about just how awful it is, I think I want to risk watching it. Only when there is absolutely NOTHING else that I could be doing with my life, so probably not for the next year or so.
Mike Conley
19. NomadUK
jlyman@4: Actually, I waded through that book when I was much younger, and, unfortunately, it sucked, too. It was one of those cases in which I kept on going because I knew there had to be a payoff for all the pain, but there never was. L Ron Hubbard just plain sucked.
Ian Tregillis
20. ITregillis
madogvelkor @ 9:

I never saw Mission to Mars, so you could very well be right! I'm tempted to Netflix it now, except for the fact that it's being compared to Battlefield Earth.

arachnejericho @ 10:

Since I haven't seen M2M, I can only guess, but I suspect that it also (c) doesn't use a wipe for (almost) every single scene transition in the film. Seriously, what was up with that?

BMcGovern @ 13:

I submit that Red Zone Cuba and Battlefield Earth are both surpassed in sheer awfulness by Monster A-Go-Go. Even worse than the legendary Manos, imho. I say that while I gaze upon the smoking cinder that used to be my soul before watching Monster... twice.
A G
21. grilojoe77
I saw this one at the theater as well. I was on a first date (sort of) and spent the rest of the afternoon apologizing for having chosen that film, of all of them showing at the time, to watch. I'd read the book a couple of times before the movie came out and really enjoyed the nuances of the story. I wondered how they were going to fit 1000+ pages of story into 2 hours. Easy. They didn't. The end of the film is around page 300 or so in the book. After having read the book and seen the train wreck of a film, I thought it would have been better suited to something like a miniseries (if it were ever to be committed to film again).
Brian Roloff
22. Ronin-alTyr
I was one of those who saw it way after, thinking it was so bad that surely there would be things to enjoy and mock… No. I have NEVER sat through a worse movie. I honestly don’t know why I didn’t just throw in the towel and abandon it, but I sat through the whole thing. I cannot recall one single redeeming quality/moment or instance within this entire flick. If you have escaped it so far, count yourself as fortunate, as I will never get those 2 hours of my life back. If you disbelieve me, well I tried to warn you. I can’t believe ITregillis sat through it twice. Did you lose a bet? Either way, I’m sorry for you. I wish I would have listened to those who said not to waste my time.
Ian Tregillis
23. ITregillis
Ronin-alTyr @ 22:

I don't know why I did it, either. It wasn't the smartest thing I've ever done. (The second time was to see the Rifftrax version, but still...)
john massey
24. subwoofer
This movie blew... I say this as I have only seen a half hour of the beast, but it was enough. That is a half hour of my life I am never getting back.

I remember getting warnings from folks that if you bail in the theater a max of a half hour, you can get your money back. I stuck it out past the 5 min mark hoping it would get better, but it didn't and life is too short to live through this train wreck. IMHO, about the only thing that would have made this better is a laugh track so the movie did not take itself so seriously. Betcha this is one movie that Travolta really wanted to call "do-over" on. And the talking dogs movies... and Wild Hogs, and his recent stab at comedy with Robin Williams...

Woof™.
Nicholas Alcock
25. NullNix
NomadUK@19: The book sucked so badly that I'd recommend, if you're curious about it, reading Dave Langford's annihilation of it instead (reprinted in _The Silence of the Langford_). It's much, much funnier, and points out the worst plot hole in the history of the human race at the same time.
YouDont NeedToKnow
26. necrosage2005
Honestly I don't see why all of the hatred for this movie exists. Granted I don't think that it was Oscar worthy, but then again, the crap that DOES win I don't think deserves it, either. I'm not going to say that it is a favorite movie, but I can actually watch it from beginning to end and not want to kill myself like you people obviously all do.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment