Tue
Mar 2 2010 3:48pm
Caprica S1, Ep 5: “There Is Another Sky”

After the intensity of “Gravedancing,” “There is Another Sky” provides a welcome respite, focusing in on the smaller stories, providing closure for some, and endless possibilities for others. Tamara Adama—remember her?—is still in V-World, trying to find her way out. The “other sky” of the episode title hangs over New Cap City, a game in V-World that takes place in a virtual, lawless version of Caprica City. Its players, one of whom is a cute boy her age, discover that she has a special ability. Since she is all avatar, she can’t be de-rezzed, which is advantageous in a game where once you de-rezz, you’re locked out of the game and can never come back. They agree to “help her get home” if she is willing to help them pull a heist that would improve their status in the game. Meanwhile, Joseph is having trouble dealing with his son as he continues to struggle with his grief, pushing Willie closer to Sam and the values of the Tauron underworld, and Daniel Graystone deals with the possible loss of his company by introducing the profitability of a cylon slave race.

This episode finally puts the Adamas’ place in the Battlestar universe into sharper focus by reminding us that there were two daughters resurrected in the virtual world. So much focus has been placed on Zoe Graystone that Caprica was starting to feel lopsided. That’s changed with “There Is Another Sky.” I have to be honest, up until now I thought that Sina Najafi (Willie) and Genevieve Buechner (Tamara) were the weakest links in the cast, which was disappointing, considering that the Adama storyline is my favorite, but this episode allowed them to shine.

Najafi has been cute up until now, but not really anything more than a pout, big eyes, and long eyelashes that make you go “awww!” It’s been said that on Tauron, someone Willie’s age would be a man, and Najafi did an admirable job in the first episode in which he was really allowed to deal with that. From pummeling a much bigger opponent who insulted his Tauron heritage, to defying his father, to solemnly saying goodbye to his mother and sister, he displayed a surprising maturity. Interestingly, Willie in his defiance taught his father about maturity and being a man, forcing him to work toward stepping up and being a father again. Willie’s defiance teaches Joseph that men are mature enough to know when it’s time to let go, when pain and grief has stopped being normal and started being a crutch. However, Willie also seems to have picked up Sam’s violent streak. The question then becomes, will he be a Tauron man, a Caprican man, or will he learn to balance the two and become a kind of man that neither his father, nor his uncle could ever be? (Namely, Edward James Olmos.)

Buechner has an unselfconscious, natural ease about her, and her journey from vulnerable, confused naïf to gun-wielding mistress of V-World happened so subtly it would be easy to mistake it for an accident, but it is clear there is talent there. Her Tamara is less showy than Torresani’s Zoe, but in the end it is she who is free to walk an entire world (albeit a virtual one) with a gun in her hand, strong and in control of her own destiny. It’s a compelling juxtaposition. Tamara is trapped in a virtual world, and yet she is free to roam a place that feels natural to her; where the rules are designed to benefit her, and from where she can communicate with the outside world via those over whom she now has control. I’m looking forward to seeing where this newfound power takes her. Zoe, meanwhile, has the outside world, but she’s trapped in a body that’s not her own and she, for now, lives at the mercy of her father, who unknowingly places his daughter in an uncomfortable position.

OK, she has to rip off her own cylon arm, so maybe it’s a bit more than uncomfortable.

That scene, in which Daniel convinces his board members that the future of Graystone Industries rests on the back of cylons, made the episode. In one powerful moment, Eric Stoltz both scared the living bejeezus out of me and made me want to be the guest of honor at the party in Daniel Graystone’s pants. There’s something compelling about power, isn’t there? It is in this scene that the connection to Battlestar Galactica is felt most strongly. Daniel basically says that the future of his company is in creating slaves. Not only creating them, but designing them so that people who buy them can feel emotionally connected to them even as they are having them do all the work. We know that later, the cylons are not too pleased with second-class citizenship, to put it mildly, and that resentment leads to war. It’s chilling, then, to watch someone have that first thought; to come up with a justification for creating a new species simply to work for us, and not even for any sort of high-minded reason, but merely to save himself and his company. Meanwhile, Torresani, for once, isn’t spunky, or snotty, or a know-it-all as Zoe. For the first time, we see her truly vulnerable. When she first steps into the room as the cylon, she seems full of pride at being her father’s best creation. When Daniel talks about the “brilliant mind” inside the cylon, Zoe beams. For once, it seems, she has genuine approval from her father. So, when she is asked to obey unconditionally and ordered to rip off her own arm, she is visibly deflated, and it’s heartbreaking to watch Avatar Zoe pull at her tiny, braceleted arm as the cylon complies.

The kids are not all right on Caprica, but Tamara, Zoe, and Willie each display strength in their own way, and it’s fascinating to think about how it seems that they will be teaching the adults of Caprica as much, if not more, than they have been taught.

Maybe one of them can teach Sam how to wear a shirt to a funeral.


Teresa Jusino was born on the same day that Skylab fell. Coincidence? She doesn’t think so. She is a contributor to PinkRaygun.com, a webzine examining geekery from a feminine perspective. Her work has also been seen on PopMatters.com, on the sadly-defunct literary site CentralBooking.com, edited by Kevin Smokler, and in the Elmont Life community newspaper. She is currently writing a web series for Pareidolia Films called The Pack, which is set to debut Summer 2010! Get Twitterpated with Teresa, Follow The Pack or visit her at The Teresa Jusino Experience.

15 comments
Fake Name
1. ThePendragon
I thought that Tamara's transition from innocent little lost girl to gun wielding bad-ass was far too sudden and felt forced. Aside from that it was a great episode. Although more and more it's becoming hard to see how Willie will end up being the Adama we all know. Maybe they are writing themselves into a corner, or maybe they have a plan . . .
rick gregory
2. rickg
Pendragon,

remember we have decades until we 'meet' the BSG Adama. Willie's showing some fire already and we're just a few weeks into his life without his mom and sister. He's got a LOT of growing to do yet.

Tamara isn't yet the master of V World.. but she's made a decision to use her nature to her advantage. If she is displayed from now on as a hard assed chick vs someone who's just found out that she's dead in the real world and THIS is it for her then I'll have a problem.

Daniel's pitch was, for me, the weak point. He argues that the cyclons are sentient... not just highly advanced expert systems in a walking body, not even just intelligent, but sentient. He proposes that they create a new, conscious race and use them as slaves... and no one has an issue with this? No one even sees that there might be a wee bit of resentment? OK, it's one scene in one show... but that was an issue for me - the board was too passive and it was just a set piece for Daniel. Too, Daniel's crossed the line from ruthless, egotistical founder to outright evil here. You can't believe it's fine to create a sentient race and then enslave it (and have its first member mutilate itself) and be anything but evil.

Zoe, by the way, need to become less of a ghost in the machine and more of an active character - I wonder if this is the impetus for her doing that.

Oh and... god the art direction is amazing. Just stunning stuff.
Andrew Gray
3. madogvelkor
I think there's a bit of self-loathing and self-rejection there in Tamara's character. Note how she tells the boy to go back to the real world and do something with his life. It's sort of like saying that she herself isn't real. There's a darkness developing in her.

I'm still wondering which of them - Zoe or Tamara will develop into the Cylon race that we know. Zoe is in the prototype, but they don't seem to be able to replicate her yet. Meanwhile Tamara is running around free.

I suppose they could both lead to the creation of the Cylons we know from BSG. The Cylons have the monotheism of Zoe, but they also half-inhabit a virtual world like Tamara's. And Tamara's control over the v-world reminds me that the Colonials had to seriously downgrade their computer technology during the war to prevent it being taken over.
Teresa Jusino
4. TeresaJusino
Daniel's been playing God ever since he tried to bring his daughter back to life. "A difference that makes no difference is no difference", and all of that.

It doesn't surprise me that no one reacted (though Luciana Carro, surprisingly, looked 'troubled'). These are people who care more about profit than children rotting themselves from the inside out via holoband. I also don't think they really have a concept of what Daniel is talking about, or think that he's actually able to accomplish it. That one guy (who's name I forget) asked about the "practical applications", and Daniel was the only one who seemed to grasp that cylons would be more than just products. I think the board members are just happy that he's thought of a way, ANY way, to replace their biggest money maker.

And I don't think Daniel's evil. People are capable of rationalizing all sorts of things to themselves and others. Remember that in the future, people STILL don't see cylons as people or sentient beings even when they become "skin jobs." I think Daniel's human, and I think humanity as a whole is capable of some pretty evil things.
Alex Brown
5. Milo1313
Another great review, Teresa!

I hate to bring up BSG all the time, but a good part of why I watch this show - besides that it's awesome - is because I like seeing hints of the future. On that note, Tamara reminds me an awful lot of Boomer and how she's on the fence about what side to go to. Without spoilage, it's interesting to see this paralleled in a teenage girl and I can't wait to see how she ends up, if she goes full avatar/Cylon or tries to recapture her humanity - and to what lengths she'll go to achieve which ever she chooses.

I also wouldn't mind being in Daniel Graystone's pants, but for an entirely different and very smexy reason.

Pendragon @ 1: I also don't think it was forced. I think, whether or not she realizes the implications of this, she understands she no longer exists in the real world. She can do whatever she wants with no responsibilities and without being culpability to anything or anyone. If you suddenly found out that you don't even exist, that you are nothing, I think you'd latch onto whatever personality you could find. In her case she's feeling empty and alone and frightened and being the badass with the biggest gun is the personality that helps her survive enough to try and get out of V World. We all do desperate things to survive...

rickg @ 2: No, I don't think they'd have a problem with creating a slave race because they all realize they aren't really a "race", not in the way they - or we - think of them. I think they think of them in the same way we think of oxen. You don't worry that the oxen pulling the cart might be bored or want to go see what's in that patch of woods over there or would like a nice new yoke to match their hooves. You harness them and put them to work, feed them, and lock them up at night, except their oxen don't have to be fed and are a helluva lot creepier looking.

madogvelkor @ 3 Thank you for pointing out that bit about where the Cylon mentality came from. I hadn't thought of that yet. Brill :)
KateTW
6. KateTW
This was such a fun episode. My biggest caveat is the heavy hand with the music. I found it really distracting. The cast is made up of good actors. Let them do the acting instead of telling the audience how to feel with the music all of the time. Please directors?

The art direction was gorgeous.

I loved the boardroom scene. It felt very accurate to me somehow-- earned. Of course deciding to create a slave race would be done for those reasons-- no evil cackling mastermind-- just simple greed and hubris. I justified the board's reaction as being stunned and taking it in. Some of them could decide that its evil and try to stop it.

Those children better not teach Sam how to wear a shirt to a funeral. And may there be many funerals.
rick gregory
7. rickg
Milo1313 - But oxen aren't sentient. Daniel makes a BIG point of the Cylon with him being sentient, not merely an intelligent machine. I get that the Capricans even in BSG felt Cyclons were less, but that's a failure of their culture to me and was complicated by the fact that the Cylons had just killed billions of humans - hard to be objective or sympathetic after that. In fact, the Carpican culture hasn't been protrayed as particularly enlightened so far. Bigotry against Tauron, a willingness to enslave a new sentient race, suppression of a minority religion... before we decide that the Caprican society is just like ours, let's consider that it's like a more repressive, authoritarian version of ours.

Teresa - That people rationalize away evil doesn't make it less evil. Pick your favorite mass murdering dictator from the 20th century - they'll claim they weren't evil. Hell, we have a war criminal in The Hague right now (Radovan Karidicic, the Serb leader who led the Srebrenica massacre) and he's in the process of denying he did anything wrong. Ask the families of the thousands who died in Srebrenica or Sarajevo though....

The one definition of evil I've held to for a long time is that evil is treating people as NOT people... as less, as not human, as something other than people. Do that and you can justify experimenting on them, segregating them, hauling them to camps and incinerating them.... it's NOT something you can do to someone who's just like you, so people who do these things first decide that the chosen group is Not People. Then they can perpetrate all kinds of actions on them because they're not people so how can it be evil to, oh, have one rip its arm off?

Daniel can easily argue that Cyclons aren't in fact, human - but are they people? What he's done is take a being that has the consciousness of Zoe and made it Other, thus justifying treating it as not a person. Of course he doesn't know Zoe's in there at this point, but he can't argue that "A difference that makes no difference is no difference" and then justify abusing beings holding such a consciousness because they're not human.

In BSG, what WAS the difference between Cylons and humans? The physical makeup? If Zoe's avatar was a perfect replica of Zoe... then is the Zoe in the Cylon body Zoe? Before you argue "Of course not..." consider this - that cyclon body without Zoe's avatar is just a pile of metal.
KateTW
8. mityorkie
Anyone else notice that during Graystone's big speech he says "I don't think you understand the enormity of the moment."
Did they intentionally have him use that word "enormity" meaning something hugely inhumane and horrible, or was the intention to have a word that meant "enormousness?"
Andrew Gray
9. madogvelkor
Daniel seems to be a bit on the fence about how he views sentient machines and technology. The way he spoke with pride about the Zoe-Cylon and then proposed enslaving them and order her to rip her arm off reminded me of the way he treated the avatar Zoe -- first embracing her, then copying and using her, then mourning her.

Daniel seems to have a hard time accepting that machines could be people. This is an interesting contrast to the lab tech who was dancing with Zoe -- he seems to treat machines as people with even less reason than Daniel has. I'm looking forward to seeing if that leads anywhere.
Teresa Jusino
10. TeresaJusino
@Milo1313 - I didn't even think to parallel her and Boomer, but that comparison is really interesting!

@KateTW - Ha! Well, I was TRYING to be professional in my review...then again, I DID use the phrase "party in Daniel Graystone's pants", so...Aw to hell with it. MORE SHIRTLESSNESS PLEASE! ;)

@rickg - I guess whenever I hear someone say something is "evil", to me it makes it overly simplistic, that's all. What I meant to say is that I don't think Daniel is simply "evil mad scientist" or whatever. He's not a caricature. He's a human being capable of doing really evil things.

@mityorkie - I'm SURE they used that word on purpose. And for the record, it means both great atrocity, and large scope. So it's not as if the word was used incorrectly. (Not sure if that's what you were getting at...)

@madogvelkor - this is what fascinates me most about Daniel. He's a father, AND a scientist. He deals w/grief not by crying or talking it out, but by creating and discovering. It's as if the only way for him to express the enormity of what he's going through is to CREATE ANOTHER SPECIES. It's kind of intense.
Alex Brown
11. Milo1313
rickg @ 7: Fine, oxen were a bad example. I'll pick an example from my own heritage. I am half black, and the black side of my family are descended from slaves in Virginia and Florida. My ancestors were dragged out of Africa, stuck on ships like sardines, and flogged until death just for not picking enough cotton. Yet what was one of the reasons for not abolishing slavery? Because it was "better" for them. Many whites thought that it was better to make them work then to let them alone. And even before slaves in America you had slavery all over the world. The ancient Romans and Greeks didn't throw pity parties for their slaves, they just beat the crap out of them. People who own slaves don't generally feel bad about it, at least not bad enough to do something about it.

Point being, I still don't think that the Board would feel that bad about it - shocked maybe, but I think those with reservations would be over that pretty quickly if the profit margins were high enough. Not only is slavery a common ideal (even in their society I'd imagine it's happened before and will happen again...as everything does...) but also because the Cylons are one step better than kidnapping a kid and forcing them to clean your house because this one won't try and run away and won't demand rights - at least not for a few years.
rick gregory
12. rickg
teresa,

Did I say "evil mad scientist"? Please don't put words in my mouth or respond to some argument I didn't make - it's frustrating. Daniel's stepped over a line - he's gone from ambitious guy making a hit product with social implications (the holobands) to someone advocating the creation and enslavement of a race of conscious beings. I get that it's PC to avoid value judgments, but isn't that evil? Now, this doesn't mean he's radically changed in an instant, but he's definitely stepped over a line. Can he step back? Will he feel the need to?

Milo - Simply because slavery has happened doesn't mean that it's a ho-hum affair forevermore. It was accepted in the US, but now would raise shock and disgust among the vast majority of Americans. Part of the issue here is that we don't know much about Caprican society so we don't really have a good bead on how they feel about this. The Tauron insults indicate an intolerant society (as do other examples), but we just don't have a lot to go on.

What mostly bothered me about the board scene was that they're just passive observers. That scene was a set piece for Daniel's speech and a big, neon sign to the audience "See, here's where it started!!" when it could have been so much more.
Teresa Jusino
13. TeresaJusino
@rickg -
"Did I say "evil mad scientist"? Please don't put words in my mouth or respond to some argument I didn't make - it's frustrating."

Um, I didn't say you said that. I said that. And all I was saying that this is what I think when other people use the word "evil." I think that word, just like "good" is a pointless label that gets bandied around when people want to see in black and white and don't want to acknowledge that there's gray.

And just to stave off you getting offended again, I'm not saying YOU PERSONALLY are saying that, but that's the association I make when I hear that. And it could be on me, and that's fine.

"Daniel's speech and a big, neon sign to the audience "See, here's where it started!!" when it could have been so much more."

Considering that the WHOLE REST OF THIS SHOW is going to be dealing with the repercussions of this moment, it doesn't bother me that they didn't tackle it in one scene. How much "more" could we really expect in that moment? Honestly, if things would've started getting preachy right off the bat, it would have turned me off as a viewer and probably struck me as "after-school special"-ish.
KateTW
14. nchashim
What annoys me in this show is seeing the same tropes set up that we see so often: the bright Caprican world where the leads are blond, that is always set in glass buildings or highly lit with light as against the dark Tauron world of "barbarian" tattooed brunettes that always set in dark poolhalls, dark living rooms and dark alleys.

I get it; I get it. I even get why Zoe has to have dark features even though she has blond parents. I feel like they are hitting me over the head with a board every week.
Teresa Jusino
15. TeresaJusino
@nchashim - I get that. And it would bother me too if they weren't trying to explore that racism and discrimination, but they are, and the blond/light Caprica vs. brunette/dark Tauron is done very much on purpose, reflecting what we might fail to see in our own everyday lives, because we're so used to the status quo that we take it for granted.

What's interesting about Caprica is that it exists in a universe where people aren't discriminated against based on gender roles or sexuality...but issues of class and race still exist. If they got rid of all of it, it wouldn't ring as true as it does.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment