Fri
Jan 22 2010 11:11am
Pilot Season Attacks!: Revenge of the Genre TV

So, with Lost entering its sixth season, Flash Forward going strong, Vampire Diaries sweeping the CW, Legend of the Seeker finding new viewers, and V inexplicably still on the air, television execs finally seem to have caught on that genre TV has a vast and devoted audience. (As long as you’re not Heroes.) As pilot season revs up, a few genre series are already in development. Let’s take a judgmental glance at the early lists, shall we?

AMC has ordered a pilot of Walking Dead, a zombie-apocalypse series based on the series of graphic novels by Robert Kirkman. The survivors (assumed to be a rag-tag bunch of strangers who must learn to work together) will fight their way across the country looking for a safe haven that I’m guess is about four seasons’ worth of travel away. The good news is that Frank Darabont is writing and directing, with Gale Anne Hurd as an executive producer, which means that the sensibility will be properly cinematic.

Fox, not wasting any time with source material that might require reading, has decided to make an American spinoff of Torchwood. In theory this works, since Torchwood field offices could be anywhere. However, given how the original Torchwood can be even in the hands of the capable BBC production team, this has the potential to be the train wreck of the season. (Don’t get me wrong, it would be awesome if John Barrowman crossed the pond with his Captain Jack character intact and started kissing men all over the place. However, this is Fox, where the only same-sex kissing they want is between two dewy young women—ideally in dream sequences or between brainwashed dolls, so it doesn’t have to be canonically addressed—so I’m not exactly sure what episodes of Torchwood they watched before they ordered this pilot.)

Meanwhile, CBS is remaking Hawaii Five-O. They must not have gotten the genre memo.

And Summit entertainment, flush with cash and not about to lose its stranglehold on the teenage demographic, must have been looking for a TV series ever since The Vampire Diaries cornered the small-screen teen-vamp market, and they seem at last to have found one. They’re developing a series based on Push, a movie about government-monitored superhumans. The feature film starred Chris “The Human Torch” Evans as a telekinetic who fights against government agents while trying not to look like a pedophile opposite the underclothed Dakota Fanning. Watchmen vet David Hayter is set to write and produce, so the series will be a lot like the movie, only with more slow motion.

Weirdly, it has yet to be picked up by a network, though for my money, I suspect NBC is just counting the hours until they can put Heroes out of its misery and scoop this pilot up like a lump of gold out of a muddy riverbed.

And these are just the early announcements. This won’t be the last we hear of genre pilots for next year; now that genre television no longer has the niche stigma it used to have (especially if you can keep the effects budget down), it’s become the next “Once-successful professional returns to his small hometown and learns charming life lessons.” Which, frankly: progress. Let’s just hope CBS doesn’t wait too long to get in on this game and pick up a genre pilot for a 9pm time slot; Hawaii Five-O isn’t going to lead itself in!


Genevieve cannot even believe they are serious about this Hawaii Five-O thing. She groans about horrible TV on her blog.

9 comments
Sarah Wilson
1. Wilson
I liked the movie Push, but I can't think that it would make a good show. Only time will tell of course. And I would definitely watch a torchwood set on this side of the pond, or better yet, bring the original to network tv.
Fred Coppersmith
2. FCoppersmith
I thought Push, the movie, had a lot of unexplored potential and was memorable mostly for its silly climactic fight scene (in what I'm guessing was a rainbow explosion factory) and Dakota Fanning's wholly unconvincing drunk scene. Oh, and the Hong Kong locations were colorful and neat. There was some intriguing world-building the movie did practically nothing with that a series could really explore. (Imagine a Heroes with some logic and rules behind the powers. And moreover a world where those powers are an accepted norm.)

I don't think a series will explore that, and it probably is just being pursued as a Heroes clone (which nobody wants). But it definitely sounds like a better idea than either a Torchwood or Hawaii Five-O remake.
Michael Curry
3. mcurry
A Hawaii Five-O without James MacArthur, Zulu and Jack Lord's hair is blasphemy!

And I think any FOX version of Torchwood will be frighteningly bad.
goshawk
4. goshawk
Push - the movie - was excellent sci-fi, particularly the way it emphasized how you really want the best precognitives on your side. The set-up was thoughtful and the movie made amazing use of its Hong Kong setting. Done well, a series based on the movie could be a really fun vehicle for good sci-fi. Of course, done poorly, it'll be yet another show about people with Kewl Powers fighting each other with lame SFX.

I'm REALLY hoping they do it well. There was so much potential for awesome in the film.
Carl Rigney
5. cdr
I totally agree with goshawk@4.

But I also kind of like the idea of mixing the two genres, as in "Once-successful superhero returns to his small hometown and learns charming life lessons.” Maybe I'm just nostalgic for The Griffin comic.
David Platt
6. The Not So Dark One
I sky plussed a movie the other week - called Revolution.

About another world ruled by Us and building to revolution over unfair taxes etc.

Wasn't great but was starting to build when it just finished. No explination - no warning. Turns out it was just a feature length pilot!

http://movies.sky.com/review/revolution-2009

Sooooo angry at Sky for wasting my time - never even mentioned it in the info box.

Whilst Im on it - I also hate the way they always leave Pilots as the first in the series and then make sweeping changes that were just supposed to ignore - please just remake the first episode!

Grump.
goshawk
7. irvingprime
Torchwood? They want to do an American version of Torchwood????

Let me see. Without an immortal leader, it's just Men in Black. Or worse, Special Unit 2. I'm really afraid Hawaii Five-Oh will be better.
Alex Brown
8. Milo1313
If Capt. Jack does cross over, he'll definitely have to be "made" bi - omnisexual won't translate well onto Fox - or, worse, straight. And we'll lose Evie Myles (she just doesn't have that American TV actress "look", no matter how great she is as Gwen...and Middle America will have a helluva time understanding her Welsh accent).

In a perfect world they'd open up Torchwood 4 in the States with an all new cast and Torchwood 5 back in the UK with Barrowman, Myles, and Kai Owen plus newbies (dear gods please not Mickey and Martha) and allow cross-pondage crossovers with them and Doctor Who + Companion. But, alas, the world is a dark and foreboding place and this will probably end up being a (crappy) retcon rather than a continuation.
YouDont NeedToKnow
9. necrosage2005
Its about time that some worthwhile shows got back on TV. I hope that they are all successful, even Hawaii 5-0. I'd also really like to see an emopire (emotional + vampire) killer, like the Necroscope series, be brought to life either on TV or in the movies. I'm so sick and tired of these whiny teen "vampires." If they are even a few decades old (more than 3, I'd say) don't all of these people, writers and fans, get that they are pedophiles if they are still going to school and hanging out with teens? You'd think that they'd have graduated by now and not need to go to school for a few hundred years. Either that, or they are just that stupid and are held back that often, probably due to them having to miss gym class on bright and sunny days.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment