Thu
Nov 26 2009 3:39pm
“Phoenix rise from ashes grey”: Steven Brust’s Phoenix

Maybe it’s just me, but it seems like when things are going wrong—your wife is ready to leave you, all your notions about yourself and the world are getting turned around, everything you trusted is becoming questionable—there’s nothing like having someone try to kill you to take your mind off your problems.

Phoenix (1990) completes the story begun in Teckla and starts a whole new phase of Vlad Taltos’s life. It’s the story of how Vlad Taltos the Jhereg assassin is sent on a mission by a god, and everything changes. It’s written in the general form of a “how to assassinate” manual, and yet it’s the furthest from that pattern of story of any of the books so far. I don’t know if it would be a good introduction to the series—I suspect not, I suspect that it works best if you already know the characters. For the first time, we meet Zerika, the Empress. For the first time we get to see somewhere outside the Empire. It’s a different kind of book. Did anyone start here? Did it work? I really can’t tell.

This is the first one I have in a nice edition—the British publishers gave up after Taltos, perhaps surprised that nobody bought books with such awful covers.

If you hate Teckla, you may hate Phoenix too, but I never did. Unlike Teckla it has many saving moments—“where I come from, we call this a drum.” There’s trouble between Vlad and Cawti, there’s an Easterners and Teckla uprising, but that isn’t the whole focus, the book doesn’t get sunk into it.

The phoenix is a bird, mythical in our world but presumably real in Dragaera, though we’re never shown one. It “sinks into decay” and “rises from ashes grey.” Vlad seems to believe that nobody is born a Phoenix unless a phoenix is passing overhead when they’re born, but in the Paarfi books we see ordinary members of the House of the Phoenix, they just almost all died in Adron’s Disaster. The Cycle is in the House of the Phoenix and Zerika (the only living member of the House of the Phoenix, a reborn Phoenix rising from the ashes) is Phoenix Emperor. It’s hard to say what it’s like to be a Phoenix apart from being Empress, what they’d be like in another House’s reign. If it’s true that as Alexx Kay has calculated the Cycle will turn in 61 years, perhaps Vlad will still be alive to see. In any case, Zerika is the Phoenix that the book mentions, and for Vlad to behave like a Phoenix means putting the good of the Empire above his own concerns. Vlad’s constantly sacrificing himself for something or other in this book, and ends by betraying the Jhereg to the Empire and going into exile.

Brust must already have been gearing up to write The Phoenix Guards when he wrote Phoenix. There are a number of mentions of how things were before the Interregnum, which has never been mentioned before, and one mention of Paarfi himself, when Cawti is reading one of his romances. My favourite of these is when Vlad and Cawti have a choice of crossing the city by weary walking or nauseating teleporting and they wish that there were another option, like the carriages people used to have before they could casually teleport everywhere. The amulet Noish-pa makes Vlad against the nausea caused by teleporting, or “crossing fairyland” as he puts it, is one of my favourite moments—the nausea has been established and taken for granted and it turns out that there’s been a way to fix it all the time.

I tend to think of these books as having progressing time and gap filling. In progressing time, Phoenix is the last of the books in which Vlad Taltos is an assassin based in Adrilankha with an organization and an office with a secretary (genuinely shocking betrayal by Melestav, after so long) and Kragar coming in unnoticed. Vlad’s spent a lot of time away from the office in the books, but that’s always been there behind him. There is a sense of death and rebirth about Phoenix, endings and new beginnings, whatever Vlad is in the subsequent books, he’s not that.

In chronological order it would be Jhegaala next, and I’ve never read them like that. (Next time!) In fact, onward to The Phoenix Guards, and thence Athyra.


Jo Walton is a science fiction and fantasy writer. She’s published eight novels, most recently Half a Crown and Lifelode, and two poetry collections. She reads a lot, and blogs about it here regularly. She comes from Wales but lives in Montreal where the food and books are more varied.

9 comments
Tex Anne
1. TexAnne
I have always wondered where the next generation of Phoenixes will come from, assuming that Sethra and/or Verra don't have something or someone up their sleeves. Zerika has a fondness for Easterners, but are the two sorts of humans genetically compatible? As things stand now, a mixed-House child would never be allowed to ascend the throne, even as a Decadent Phoenix.

OTOH the Cycle is long, and Mr. Brust is inventive.
JohneCook
2. JohneCook
Phoenix is one of my favorite Vlad books. The rescue of Vlad by his friends from the thing is classic.

And you won't get through The Phoenix Guards in a day - one of my favorite books of all time.
Jo Walton
3. bluejo
TexAnne: I don't think they can be interfertile, or there would be half-breeds around. The fate of the Phoenix House in the next cycle is a mystery.
JohneCook
4. Michael S. Schiffer
I'm in the camp of Teckla-haters, and I found this book a huge relief. First of all, the explicit acknowledgment that the Marxist revolutionary movement wasn't a good fit for the Empire even in its own terms. But also, it seemed to back off of the characterization of Cawti as hypersensitive and utterly unwilling to give Vlad the benefit of the doubt. (And vice versa, probably, but it's Vlad's head we're in.) It's probably a realistic portrayal of a divorce in some ways, but Cawti really seemed to have lost half her IQ and street smarts in Teckla, and recovers a lot here. Before Phoenix, I wasn't sure there was a way to go forward from Teckla (which making the next book a prequel reinforced). Afterwards, it seemed as if it had dodged the rocks and could move into its new channel.
john mullen
5. johntheirishmongol
This is one of my fave books in the series. However, one thing that was never made clear to me was exactly why Verra wanted to have the king, unless it was to maintan the cycle and that Kelly, et al were a real threat, which I found too hard to believe. Definately the setup book for the rest of the series.

Jo, I don't know if you have read this short story in the Vlad universe but here is a link. It is older so may have been before he had worked out a lot of things, but you might find it interesting
http://mindstalk.net/brust/dream.html

I am right in the middle of Jhegaala but its a good thing I had a head start, cuz you are zooming thru the series. I did PG, and 500 Years After too, but still have 3 books on that side to reread
Sol Foster
6. colomon
John, I've assumed that Issola means this story is now apocryphal.

And count me in the camp that was none too thrilled with Teckla, Phoenix, and Athyra. Seems odd now, as I have loved every Vlad book since those, and the Khaavren books even more so.
Jo Walton
7. bluejo
Johntheirishmongol: Well, what are the possibilities, from what we know.

1) Verra wanted to kill the king to start a war to start conscription to get everyone's mind off the revolution. That's what she told Vlad. It didn't work (by the blood on Verra's floor...) but she might have been telling the truth.

1a) Verra might have done this with this intention but specifically to get Cawti's mind of the revolution. In that case, it didn't work.

So let's assume she isn't an idiot (though what evidence do we have for that again?) and look at this in a results based way.

2) Verra might have wanted Vlad out of Adrilankha and out of the Hjereg. She might have wanted things to happen exactly as they did happen.

3) Verra might have wanted a Greenaere drummer in Adrilankha for mysterious reasons of her own.

Anyone got any better ones?
Alexx Kay
8. AlexxKay
"If it’s true that as Alexx Kay has calculated the Cycle will turn in 61 years"

Nitpick: That is the *earliest* that the Cycle could turn, given what we know so far. It could be considerably later.

TexAnne: A conversation between the gods in one of the Paarfi books suggests (in vague and mystical language) that there are enough recessive Phoenix genes in the general population that a 'pure' Phoenix could come about. I suspect that the gods might well meddle in certain people's romantic affairs for a few millenia to try and bring that about.

johntheirishmongol: Though Kelly was never (in Verra's eyes) a threat to the *Cycle*, he *was* still a big enough threat to peace and commerce that he could (and in fact did) cause a lot of trouble. In our own history, foreign wars have often quelled that sort of trouble at home, and one gathers that the same has worked in the past for Verra.

I think I recall Brust saying that he now regards "A Dream of Passion" as just what it says in the title, a dream.
JohneCook
9. Petlyn
Steven Brust has said that "A Dream of Passion" should definitely be considered non-canon. He wrote it for a convention he attended where Roger Zelazny was also a guest. It recreates a brief scene near the beginning of "Nine Princes in Amber," when Corwin and Random in their car meet a rider in the rain, from the other point of view. He has also said that Vlad is a liar, and nothing he says can be guaranteed. This may be just a way to leave him an out for any mistakes.

Subscribe to this thread

Receive notification by email when a new comment is added. You must be a registered user to subscribe to threads.
Post a comment